Skip to content
ACT · English

Comma usage

Comma usage appears in 94 reviewed ACT questions and sits in English. Below are worked examples showing exactly how the exam tests it, with the answer marked and every distractor explained.

How Comma usage is tested

Example 1Easier
The hikers packed their gear carefully, making sure to bring extra water, sunscreen, and a detailed map of the trail. Which of the following correctly uses commas in the sentence above?
  1. AThe hikers packed their gear carefully, making sure to bring extra water, sunscreen, and a detailed map of the trail.Correct
  2. BThe hikers packed their gear carefully, making sure to bring extra water sunscreen and a detailed map of the trail.
  3. CThe hikers packed their gear, carefully, making sure to bring extra water, sunscreen, and a detailed map of the trail.
  4. DThe hikers packed their gear carefully making sure to bring extra water, sunscreen, and a detailed map of the trail.

Why A is right

The original sentence correctly uses a comma after 'carefully' to set off the participial phrase 'making sure to bring...' and uses commas to separate the three items in the series (water, sunscreen, and a detailed map).
Why the other 3 choices miss
B
Incorrect because items in a series must be separated by commas; omitting commas between 'water,' 'sunscreen,' and 'a detailed map' creates ambiguity.
C
Incorrect because placing a comma around 'carefully' incorrectly treats it as a nonrestrictive element, disrupting the flow of the sentence.
D
Incorrect because the participial phrase 'making sure to bring extra water...' is an introductory modifier that requires a comma after 'carefully' to separate it properly.
Example 2Easier
Marcus studied for hours every night[,] but he still struggled to understand the complex chemistry equations. Is the comma before 'but' necessary?
  1. ANo, because the sentence is too short to need a comma.
  2. BNo, because commas are never used before coordinating conjunctions.
  3. CYes, because 'but' here joins two independent clauses, and a comma before a coordinating conjunction connecting independent clauses is required.Correct
  4. DYes, because a comma is required before any coordinating conjunction.

Why C is right

When a coordinating conjunction (FANBOYS) joins two independent clauses, a comma is placed before the conjunction. 'Marcus studied for hours every night' and 'he still struggled to understand the complex chemistry equations' are both independent clauses.
Why the other 3 choices miss
A
Incorrect because sentence length has no bearing on comma rules; the grammatical structure (two independent clauses) determines punctuation.
B
Incorrect because commas are frequently and correctly used before coordinating conjunctions that join two independent clauses.
D
Incorrect because a comma is not required before every coordinating conjunction — only when the conjunction joins two independent clauses, not when it joins words or phrases.
Example 3Easier
The recipe calls for two cups of flour[,] one cup of sugar[,] and half a cup of butter. Are the commas used correctly in this sentence?
  1. ANo; commas should be replaced with semicolons throughout the series.
  2. BNo; commas should only be used if the items in the series are longer phrases.
  3. CNo; the final comma before 'and' should be removed.
  4. DYes; commas correctly separate three items in a series.Correct

Why D is right

The Oxford comma (serial comma) correctly separates three or more items in a series. Using commas between 'flour,' 'sugar,' and 'butter' is standard ACT English convention. No revision is needed.
Why the other 3 choices miss
A
Incorrect because semicolons are used to separate items in a series only when the items themselves contain internal commas, which is not the case here.
B
Incorrect because comma usage in a series is not determined by the length of the items; single words in a series still require commas.
C
Incorrect because while some style guides make the Oxford comma optional, ACT English treats the serial comma as correct and preferred usage.

Studied alongside

Other concepts from English.