The hikers found the trail [to be more challenging than/more challenging then/more challenging as/as more challenging than] they had expected.
Which phrasing makes a correct comparison?
- Amore challenging then
- Bmore challenging as
- Cas more challenging than
- Dto be more challenging thanCorrect
Why D is right
'Found the trail to be more challenging than' is the correct comparative construction. 'Than' (not 'then') is used for comparisons, and 'to be' correctly completes the infinitive after 'found.'
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- Incorrect because 'then' is a time adverb, not a comparative conjunction; 'than' is required for comparisons.
- B
- Incorrect because 'as' introduces equal comparisons ('as...as'), not 'more...than' comparisons.
- C
- Incorrect because 'as more challenging than' mixes equal comparison ('as') with unequal comparison ('more...than'), creating a contradictory and ungrammatical construction.
The following questions refer to the passage below.
Passage 3 (Natural Science): The concept of a keystone species—one whose presence has a disproportionately large effect on its ecosystem relative to its abundance—emerged from a famous series of experiments conducted along the rocky intertidal zones of the Pacific Northwest coast in the 1960s. Marine ecologist Robert Paine removed sea stars of the species Pisaster ochraceus from a stretch of shoreline and observed what happened next. The results were dramatic: without sea stars to prey on mussels, mussel populations exploded and crowded out nearly every other species from the habitat. Biodiversity collapsed. When Paine reintroduced the sea stars, the ecosystem gradually recovered. The experiment demonstrated that some species exert a regulatory influence far exceeding what their population size would suggest.
The concept quickly gained traction across ecology and conservation biology. Wolves in Yellowstone National Park became the most famous case study. After wolves were reintroduced to Yellowstone in 1995 following a seventy-year absence, researchers documented a cascade of ecological changes. Wolf predation reduced elk populations and altered elk behavior—elk began avoiding riverbanks where wolves could ambush them. Freed from overgrazing, riverbank vegetation recovered. Tree roots stabilized eroding streambanks. Rivers began to change course. These second- and third-order effects were termed a "trophic cascade"—a chain of changes moving through multiple levels of the food web.
Not every ecologist accepts the keystone species concept without reservation. Critics argue that it oversimplifies complex ecological relationships and risks creating a misleading narrative in which ecosystems are stable systems disrupted only by the removal of a single critical species. Real ecosystems are constantly changing, shaped by climate, disease, human activity, and chance. A species that behaves as a keystone in one context may be far less influential in another.
Despite these qualifications, the concept has had significant practical influence on conservation policy. Efforts to protect and restore apex predators—wolves, sharks, sea otters, and large cats—are often justified in part by keystone arguments. The logic is appealing: if a single species can restructure an entire ecosystem, then targeted protection of that species may represent an efficient use of limited conservation resources.
Question: Compared to the sea star experiment, the Yellowstone wolf case study is presented in the passage as
- Aa refutation of Paine's findings because wolves affect ecosystems through behavior, not direct predation of competitors
- Ba more famous and widely cited example of keystone effects that includes multi-level ecosystem changesCorrect
- Cless reliable because it occurred in a terrestrial setting rather than a controlled marine zone
- Da cautionary tale about the unintended consequences of reintroducing predators to national parks
Why B is right
The passage introduces the Yellowstone case as 'the most famous case study' and describes a trophic cascade—second- and third-order effects moving through multiple food web levels. This makes it both more widely known and more complex in its demonstrated effects than the sea star experiment.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- Incorrect because wolves do engage in direct predation (of elk), and the passage presents the Yellowstone study as a confirmation, not refutation, of Paine's findings.
- C
- Incorrect because the passage does not suggest the Yellowstone study is less reliable; both examples are presented as supporting evidence for the keystone concept.
- D
- Incorrect because the passage presents the Yellowstone reintroduction as a positive example of trophic cascades, not as a cautionary tale about unintended consequences.
The following questions refer to the passage below.
Passage 1 (Humanities): Jazz pianist and composer Mary Lou Williams occupied an unusual position in the history of American music: she was among the few artists whose career bridged nearly every major era of jazz, from the stride piano tradition of the 1920s through bebop in the 1940s to free jazz and sacred music in the 1960s and 1970s. Born in Atlanta in 1910 and raised in Pittsburgh, Williams began performing professionally as a teenager, quickly developing a reputation for technical virtuosity and harmonic invention that attracted the attention of leading musicians decades older than she was.
In the 1930s, Williams joined Andy Kirk's orchestra as a staff arranger and sometime pianist. Her arrangements gave the orchestra a distinctive, swinging character that set it apart from its contemporaries, and her work drew the attention of major bandleaders including Duke Ellington and Benny Goodman, both of whom commissioned pieces from her. Unlike most women musicians of the era, who were expected to perform as featured vocalists or novelty acts, Williams was recognized primarily as a composer and arranger of exceptional ability.
Williams's willingness to evolve musically was as notable as her talent. When bebop emerged in the 1940s as a young musicians' revolt against the commercial constraints of swing, Williams was in her thirties—an age at which most jazz musicians of her generation had settled into established styles. Instead, she immersed herself in the new idiom, befriending its architects—Thelonious Monk, Dizzy Gillespie, Charlie Parker—and incorporating bebop's complex harmonics into her own writing. Her apartment became an informal salon where young bebop musicians gathered, and she served as mentor and advocate for an entire generation.
In her later years, Williams converted to Roman Catholicism and channeled her musical energies into sacred composition, producing masses and other liturgical works that blended jazz vocabulary with Catholic tradition. Critics were sometimes uncertain how to categorize this work, but Williams saw no contradiction, treating all of it by the same simple standard: whether or not it swung. This lifelong refusal to treat genre distinctions as more important than musical authenticity ran through her entire career.
Williams died in 1981, celebrated but never quite as famous as the male contemporaries she had influenced and outlasted. The relative neglect of her legacy reflects persistent patterns in the documentation of jazz history, in which women's contributions have too often been treated as footnotes to stories centered on men.
Question: Compared to Williams, most women musicians of the 1930s era are described in the passage as
- Acelebrated primarily by male bandleaders who championed gender equality in jazz
- Bequally recognized for their arranging and compositional skills
- Cexpected to fulfill roles as vocalists or novelty performers rather than serious composersCorrect
- Dlargely excluded from commercial orchestras and forced to perform in informal settings
Why C is right
The passage states explicitly that 'unlike most women musicians of the era, who were expected to perform as featured vocalists or novelty acts, Williams was recognized primarily as a composer and arranger.' This contrast establishes that the norm for women was vocalist/novelty roles.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- Incorrect because the passage does not suggest that male bandleaders broadly championed gender equality; Ellington and Goodman commissioned Williams because of her talent, not as a gender equity initiative.
- B
- Incorrect because the passage draws an explicit contrast, saying Williams was unusual in being recognized as a composer; most women were not.
- D
- Incorrect because the passage does not discuss women's exclusion from commercial orchestras in general; it focuses on the roles women were expected to play within those settings.