Skip to content
ACT · Science

Experimental design

Experimental design appears in 16 reviewed ACT questions and sits in Science. Below are worked examples showing exactly how the exam tests it, with the answer marked and every distractor explained.

How Experimental design is tested

Example 1Easier
Experiment 1: A student placed three groups of bean seedlings (10 plants each) in chambers with different CO2 concentrations: 0.04% (ambient), 0.08%, and 0.16%. All other variables (light intensity, temperature, water) were held constant. After 4 weeks, the student measured average plant height. Results: CO2 Concentration | Average Height (cm) 0.04% | 22.1 0.08% | 27.6 0.16% | 31.4 Which variable was intentionally manipulated (independent variable) in this experiment?
  1. AAverage plant height
  2. BCO2 concentrationCorrect
  3. CWater availability
  4. DLight intensity

Why B is right

The independent variable is the factor the experimenter deliberately changes. In this experiment, the student varied CO2 concentration across the three groups while holding all other factors constant.
Why the other 3 choices miss
A
Incorrect because average plant height is the dependent variable — the outcome being measured, not what was changed.
C
Incorrect because water availability was also held constant as a controlled variable.
D
Incorrect because light intensity was held constant; it is a controlled variable, not the manipulated one.
Example 2Medium
Experiment 5: A student compared the transpiration rates of three plant species by measuring water loss through leaves over 4 hours under identical environmental conditions. The student sealed the roots and stems with petroleum jelly to ensure water loss occurred only through leaf surfaces. Plant Species | Leaf Surface Area (cm²) | Water Lost (mL) | Transpiration Rate (mL/cm²/hr) Cacti | 15 | 0.12 | 0.002 Oak | 240 | 62.4 | 0.065 Tobacco | 310 | 120.9 | 0.097 Why did the student seal the roots and stems with petroleum jelly?
  1. ATo prevent photosynthesis from consuming water during the measurement period.
  2. BTo increase the rate of water movement through the plant's vascular tissue.
  3. CTo prevent nutrients from entering the leaves during the experiment.
  4. DTo ensure any water loss measured could be attributed to transpiration through leaves only.Correct

Why D is right

By sealing all surfaces except the leaves, the student isolated transpiration as the only pathway for water loss. This is a control measure to ensure that the measured water loss reflects only leaf transpiration, not leakage or evaporation from stems or roots.
Why the other 3 choices miss
A
Incorrect because photosynthesis uses water internally and would not be blocked by an external sealant; also, the scale of photosynthetic water use is far smaller than transpiration rates.
B
Incorrect because sealing external surfaces with petroleum jelly would not accelerate internal vascular flow; if anything, it would have minimal effect on xylem transport.
C
Incorrect because petroleum jelly on external surfaces would not block internal nutrient transport through the vascular system.
Example 3Easier
Experiment 1: A student investigated the effect of exercise intensity on heart rate and oxygen consumption. Ten subjects exercised on a stationary bicycle at increasing wattage levels. Heart rate (bpm) and oxygen consumption (VO2, mL/kg/min) were recorded at each stage. Exercise Intensity (Watts) | Mean Heart Rate (bpm) | Mean VO2 (mL/kg/min) 0 (rest) | 72 | 3.5 50 | 98 | 12.1 100 | 128 | 22.8 150 | 158 | 34.2 200 | 183 | 45.6 250 | 194 | 55.1 Which variable serves as the dependent variable in this experiment?
  1. AThe number of subjects (10) used in the study
  2. BBoth heart rate and oxygen consumptionCorrect
  3. CThe type of exercise equipment used
  4. DExercise intensity in watts

Why B is right

The dependent variables are the outcomes measured in response to the manipulated (independent) variable. In this experiment, exercise intensity was deliberately varied, and both heart rate and VO2 were measured as responses — making both dependent variables.
Why the other 3 choices miss
A
Incorrect because the number of subjects is a study design characteristic, not a variable being measured in response to exercise intensity.
C
Incorrect because the type of equipment is a controlled variable held constant throughout the experiment.
D
Incorrect because exercise intensity is the independent variable — the factor the experimenter deliberately manipulated.

Studied alongside

Other concepts from Science.