Skip to content
AP Biology · Natural Selection

Balancing selection

Balancing selection appears in 3 reviewed AP Biology questions and sits in Natural Selection. Below are worked examples showing exactly how the exam tests it, with the answer marked and every distractor explained.

Balancing selection is any form of natural selection that keeps two or more alleles in a population instead of letting one win. Heterozygote advantage is the classic example, where Aa individuals are fitter than both AA and aa. Negative frequency-dependent selection, where a rarer phenotype has higher fitness, is another.

Why it matters

It explains why a harmful allele can stay common for many generations. Selection does not always remove variation, and sometimes it preserves it.

How the exam tests it

The sickle cell allele is the standard case. In regions with malaria, HbA/HbS carriers resist malaria without having severe sickle cell disease, so they outsurvive both homozygotes. You must name this as heterozygote advantage and explain why both alleles persist.

Don’t confuse it with

Students confuse it with stabilizing selection, but stabilizing selection favors the average phenotype of a trait, while balancing selection keeps multiple alleles present.

Balancing selection in real questions

Example 1Medium
Sickle cell disease is caused by a single amino acid substitution in hemoglobin. In regions where malaria is endemic, heterozygous carriers (HbA HbS) have higher fitness than either homozygous genotype. This is an example of:
  1. ADirectional selection favoring the HbS allele
  2. BStabilizing selection eliminating extreme phenotypes
  3. CDisruptive selection favoring both homozygous genotypes
  4. DBalancing selection through heterozygote advantageCorrect

Why D is right

Heterozygote advantage (also called overdominance) is a form of balancing selection in which heterozygous individuals have higher fitness than either homozygous genotype. HbA HbS heterozygotes have mild sickling that confers malaria resistance without the severe symptoms of sickle cell disease, maintaining both alleles in the population.
Why the other 3 choices miss
A
Incorrect. Directional selection would favor one extreme phenotype, pushing the population toward the HbS allele. But homozygous HbS individuals suffer severe disease, so the HbS allele is not universally favored.
B
Incorrect. Stabilizing selection favors the intermediate phenotype and reduces variation, but it does not specifically describe the heterozygote having higher fitness than both homozygotes in a genetic context.
C
Incorrect. Disruptive selection favors both extreme phenotypes and disfavors intermediate phenotypes. In this case, the heterozygote (intermediate) has the highest fitness.

Studied alongside

Other concepts from Natural Selection.