In C3 photosynthesis, carbon dioxide is initially fixed by the enzyme RuBisCO into a three-carbon compound. Under conditions of high temperature and low CO2 concentration, RuBisCO also fixes O2 in a process called photorespiration. Which of the following correctly describes why photorespiration is considered wasteful?
- APhotorespiration produces excess glucose that the plant must export from its leaves to prevent toxicity
- BPhotorespiration occurs only at night, when the light reactions cannot supply ATP and NADPH to the Calvin cycle
- CPhotorespiration produces surplus ATP that the cell cannot use and must dissipate as heat in the stroma
- DPhotorespiration consumes O2 and releases fixed CO2 without making sugar, lowering photosynthetic efficiencyCorrect
Why D is right
Photorespiration occurs when RuBisCO fixes O2 instead of CO2, producing a two-carbon compound (phosphoglycolate) that must be salvaged through an energy-consuming pathway. This process uses ATP and releases previously fixed CO2 without producing any sugar, effectively undoing the work of the Calvin cycle and reducing overall photosynthetic efficiency by up to 25-30% in C3 plants.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- Incorrect because photorespiration does not produce glucose. It consumes previously fixed carbon and releases CO2, resulting in a net loss of carbon rather than excess sugar that must be exported.
- B
- Incorrect because photorespiration occurs during the day (in the light), when the light reactions are active and O2 is being produced. It is enhanced by high temperature and high light conditions, not darkness.
- C
- Incorrect because photorespiration actually consumes ATP rather than producing it. It requires energy to recover the carbon from the phosphoglycolate pathway, so there is no surplus ATP to dissipate.