A researcher inhibits Complex I of the electron transport chain with rotenone. Which prediction about cellular ATP production is best supported?
- AOnly substrate-level phosphorylation would be eliminated, while glycolysis and the citric acid cycle would continue at their normal rates
- BCells would switch entirely to photosynthesis, using light energy to regenerate ATP and compensate for the lost mitochondrial output
- CTotal ATP production would be unaffected, because Complex II can accept all NADH-derived electrons and fully substitute for Complex I
- DOxidative phosphorylation would drop sharply because NADH could no longer donate electrons to the chain, though FADH2 can still enter at Complex IICorrect
Why D is right
Complex I (NADH dehydrogenase) oxidizes NADH and pumps 4H+ across the inner mitochondrial membrane. Rotenone blocks electron transfer from NADH to ubiquinone at Complex I. Consequence: (1) NADH from the citric acid cycle and pyruvate dehydrogenase cannot donate electrons, halting their re-oxidation; (2) The citric acid cycle stalls as NAD+ is depleted; (3) Only Complex II (succinate dehydrogenase, which oxidizes FADH2) can still feed electrons to ubiquinone, maintaining a partial proton gradient; (4) ATP synthase activity is greatly reduced. The cell may survive partially on glycolysis and limited ETC via Complex II.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- Substrate-level phosphorylation (in glycolysis and the TCA cycle) continues independently of the ETC; it is oxidative phosphorylation that is severely reduced. The citric acid cycle actually stalls as NAD+ is depleted, and glycolysis would be upregulated to compensate.
- B
- Animal cells cannot photosynthesize; they have no chloroplasts. Rotenone-treated cells would instead upregulate glycolysis (anaerobic fermentation) as a compensatory mechanism.
- C
- Complex I handles the majority of electron flow from NADH (produced in glycolysis, the PDH reaction, and the TCA cycle); it is not redundant. Complex II only oxidizes succinate (producing FADH2) and cannot accept NADH electrons, so it cannot compensate.
In the citric acid cycle, one acetyl-CoA (2 carbons) enters and two CO2 molecules exit per turn. How many ATP equivalents are produced per acetyl-CoA (counting only the carriers NADH, FADH2, and GTP from one turn of the cycle)?
- A4 ATP equivalents (from 1 GTP directly)
- BApproximately 10 ATP equivalents (3 NADH × 2.5 + 1 FADH2 × 1.5 + 1 GTP = 10)Correct
- C2 ATP equivalents
- D32 ATP equivalents (the total for the entire aerobic respiration of glucose)
Why B is right
Per one turn of the citric acid cycle (one acetyl-CoA): 3 NADH, 1 FADH2, 1 GTP are produced. Using modern P/O ratios: NADH → ~2.5 ATP each (via Complex I, III, IV + ATP synthase); FADH2 → ~1.5 ATP (enters at Complex II, bypassing Complex I); GTP = 1 ATP equivalent (direct substrate-level phosphorylation). Total: (3 × 2.5) + (1 × 1.5) + 1 = 7.5 + 1.5 + 1 = 10 ATP equivalents per acetyl-CoA. The older textbook values of 3 ATP/NADH and 2 ATP/FADH2 yield 12, but modern biochemistry uses the ~10 figure.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- 1 GTP is produced directly in the TCA cycle (by succinyl-CoA synthetase), but this ignores the 3 NADH and 1 FADH2 also produced per turn, which together generate approximately 9 more ATP via the ETC.
- C
- 2 ATP equivalents dramatically underestimates the TCA cycle output; the direct GTP production alone is 1, plus the electron carriers NADH and FADH2 each generate additional ATP through the ETC.
- D
- 32 ATP is the approximate total for complete oxidation of one glucose molecule (glycolysis + PDH + 2 turns TCA + ETC); one turn of the TCA cycle (from one acetyl-CoA) produces approximately 10 ATP equivalents, not 32.