An experiment compares the net photosynthesis rates of a C3 plant (wheat) and a C4 plant (corn) at 30°C in ambient air (0.04% CO2, 20% O2). At this temperature, corn's net photosynthesis rate is significantly higher than wheat's. Which biochemical difference best explains this result?
- ACorn's stomata remain open wider at 30°C, admitting more CO2 for the Calvin cycle than wheat's heat-closed stomata allow
- BCorn's C4 pathway concentrates CO2 around RuBisCO, suppressing the photorespiration that lowers wheat's net photosynthesisCorrect
- CWheat is a winter crop genetically programmed to reduce its photosynthesis at 30°C as a way to avoid summer heat damage
- DCorn has more chlorophyll molecules per leaf area, so it absorbs more photons and produces more ATP during the light reactions
Why B is right
At 30°C and ambient CO2:O2 ratios, RuBisCO's oxygenase activity (photorespiration) is significant in C3 plants like wheat—up to 25-50% of carbon fixed can be lost through photorespiration at 30°C. Corn (C4) uses the PEP carboxylase/bundle sheath system to concentrate CO2 around RuBisCO to 10-60 times atmospheric levels, making oxygenase activity negligible. This means virtually all RuBisCO reactions are carboxylase reactions in corn, giving it substantially higher net photosynthesis at warm temperatures where photorespiration most severely penalizes C3 plants.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- Both C3 and C4 plants close stomata in response to heat and water stress; greater stomatal opening in corn would also increase water loss; the advantage is in the carbon concentration biochemistry, not stomatal aperture.
- C
- Wheat and corn are both bred for productivity; wheat's lower photosynthesis at 30°C is not genetic programming for heat avoidance but rather an inherent consequence of photorespiration in C3 plants at warm temperatures.
- D
- Chlorophyll density does not generally differ enough between corn and wheat to explain large photosynthetic rate differences; the key biochemical difference is the carbon concentration mechanism, not light harvesting capacity.