The atom economy of a reaction measures what fraction of reactant atoms ends up in the desired product. For the reaction producing methanol (, ) from () and (): , what is the atom economy?
- A, because 2 of the 4 reactant molecules become products
- B, because all atoms in the reactants end up in the single product methanolCorrect
- C, because methanol has 32 of 36 total mass units from reactants
- D, because methanol contains one carbon atom out of the three total atoms (, , )
Why B is right
Atom economy . For : MW of desired product (methanol) . Sum of MW of reactants . Atom economy . This is a atom economy reaction because there is only ONE product, and ALL reactant atoms end up in that product. Reactions with atom economy are ideal from a green chemistry perspective — no waste byproducts. This reaction is used industrially (with catalyst) to produce methanol from syngas.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- Atom economy is not calculated based on the number of reactant molecules. It is calculated from molecular weights: . The count of molecules is irrelevant.
- C
- would arise if 3.5 out of 4 total mass units were in the product. But methanol () exactly equals all reactants (), giving , not .
- D
- Atom economy is calculated from molecular masses of all atoms, not from atom count. All atoms (, , and ) from and are present in methanol ().