In a Lewis structure for SO3, sulfur is shown with double bonds to each of the three oxygen atoms, placing 12 electrons around sulfur. Which statement about this structure is most accurate?
- AThe structure is incorrect because double bonds require pi bonds, which are not possible for sulfur due to its large atomic radius.
- BThe structure with three double bonds is incorrect because it gives oxygen atoms a formal charge of +1, violating the electronegativity principle.
- CThe structure is acceptable because sulfur, a period 3 element, can expand its octet, and this minimizes formal charges.Correct
- DThe structure is incorrect because sulfur cannot exceed 8 electrons; the correct structure has one double bond and two single bonds with formal charges.
Why C is right
For SO3, two valid resonance Lewis structures exist: one with three equivalent S=O double bonds (expanded octet, 12 electrons on S, formal charges 0 on all atoms) and structures with one double bond and two S-O single bonds (formal charges +2 on S and -1 on O atoms). The structure with three S=O double bonds minimizes formal charges to zero on all atoms and is generally considered the best representation for SO3 because it avoids charge separation. Sulfur can accommodate this because it is a period 3 element with accessible d orbitals.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- Sulfur can and does form pi bonds. Its atomic radius being larger than oxygen does not prevent pi bond formation; the p orbitals on adjacent atoms can overlap sideways.
- B
- In the structure with three double bonds (S=O x 3), the formal charge on each oxygen is 0, not +1. Formal charge = valence electrons - nonbonding electrons - (1/2)bonding electrons = 6 - 4 - (1/2)(4) = 0.
- D
- While the single-double-single structure is a valid resonance form, the structure with three double bonds is also accepted and preferred because it minimizes formal charges. The expanded octet is allowed for period 3 elements.