Osmotic pressure (pi = iMRT) is a colligative property. A 0.1 M NaCl solution has approximately twice the osmotic pressure of a 0.1 M glucose solution at the same temperature. Which concept explains this factor of two difference?
- ANaCl dissociates into Na+ and Cl- (i = 2), while glucose does not dissociate (i = 1).Correct
- BCl- ions are larger than glucose molecules and physically block more membrane pores, doubling the osmotic effect.
- CNa+ ions interact more strongly with water than glucose does, creating twice the hydration pressure.
- DNaCl has twice the molecular weight of glucose, so it exerts twice the pressure per gram.
Why A is right
Osmotic pressure is a colligative property — it depends on the number of solute particles per unit volume, not their identity. The van't Hoff factor (i) accounts for dissociation: i = number of particles per formula unit in solution. NaCl dissociates completely in dilute solution: NaCl → Na+ + Cl- (i = 2). Glucose is a molecular compound that does not dissociate (i = 1). With i = 2, 0.1 M NaCl effectively contributes 0.2 mol/L of particles, while 0.1 M glucose contributes 0.1 mol/L of particles. The osmotic pressure of NaCl solution is therefore twice that of the glucose solution: pi = iMRT = 2*0.1*R*T vs 1*0.1*R*T.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- B
- Osmosis occurs through a semipermeable membrane by solvent movement, not by solute pore blocking. The size of solute particles does not determine osmotic pressure — the number of particles does.
- C
- While ion hydration is a real phenomenon affecting other thermodynamic properties, osmotic pressure is a colligative effect based on particle number. The chemical identity of the particles (Na+ vs glucose) is not relevant to the osmotic pressure calculation.
- D
- Osmotic pressure is a colligative property based on particle count (molarity * van't Hoff factor), not mass. Glucose (MW=180) is much heavier than NaCl (MW=58.5), but it has lower osmotic effect per mole because it does not dissociate.