Skip to content

Free-response practice

The Argument Essay

6 points2 original prompts4 scored examples

The argument essay is the third of three essays in the AP English Language free-response section. Unlike the other two essays, it gives you no passage to analyze and no sources to cite. Instead you get a short prompt, usually a claim about how people live, learn, or govern themselves, and you argue your own position on it. Your evidence comes entirely from what you already know: history, science, current events, literature, and your own experience.

On this page · 6 sections

The essay section lasts 2 hours and 15 minutes, including a 15-minute reading period. You may write the synthesis, rhetorical analysis, and argument essays in any order. Each essay is scored out of 6 points, and together the three account for 55 percent of your exam score, so this single essay is worth roughly 18 percent. Plan about 40 minutes for it: five minutes to choose a position and outline, then thirty-five minutes of writing.

Readers score your essay on three rows. Row A, the thesis, is worth 1 point. Row B, evidence and commentary, is worth 4 points and decides most scores. Row C, sophistication, is worth 1 point, and only a small share of essays earn it. Readers judge the essay as a whole and place it on each row; they do not subtract points for individual errors. Grammar slips cost nothing unless they obscure your meaning, but errors that interfere with communication can keep you out of the top Row B score.

The skill being tested is reasoning. Readers are looking for a clear position, specific evidence, and commentary that explains exactly how each example proves your point. A collection of examples with no explanation scores low, however impressive the examples are, because one example you explain completely is worth more than three you only mention. Many prompts ask you to argue 'the extent to which' something is true. That phrasing invites a qualified answer: the claim holds in these situations, fails in those, and here is the reason.

The rubric, in plain terms

6 points, earned line by line. Readers score what is on the page, nothing else.

Thesis (Row A)1 pt

Take a position on the prompt that a reasonable person could disagree with, then defend it. The thesis can be one sentence or two sentences side by side, and it usually ends your introduction. You miss the point if you only restate the prompt, say there are 'pros and cons' without choosing, or argue about a different question than the one asked.

Evidence and Commentary (Row B)4 pts

This row is a ladder. 0 points: no relevant evidence, or the essay only repeats its thesis. 1 point: evidence is mostly general ('history shows,' 'many people') and the essay retells it without saying why it matters. 2 points: some specific evidence and some explanation, but the explanation mostly repeats the claim, or there is no clear line of reasoning. You could shuffle the paragraphs and lose nothing. 3 points: specific evidence supports all claims in a line of reasoning, and the commentary explains how some of the evidence supports that line of reasoning. Elsewhere the explanation thins out or only repeats the claim. 4 points: specific evidence backs every claim, and each example comes with commentary that shows how it proves the claim. The paragraphs build one line of reasoning from start to finish. Errors that blur meaning can block the fourth point.

Sophistication (Row C)1 pt

Earned by thinking that runs through the whole essay, not by one clever line. Ways to earn it: qualify your position and show exactly where it stops being true; take a strong opposing view seriously and work through it; show what your argument means for a bigger question; or write in a style so vivid and controlled that it makes the argument more convincing. A fancy last sentence or a list of big words does not earn it.

Practice prompts

Prompt 1

The Case for Boredom

Phones, streaming services, and endless feeds now make it possible to go a whole day without feeling bored. Some psychologists and writers say this is a loss. In their view, boredom is not a problem to fix. It is a useful signal that pushes people to think, imagine, and change their situation.

  1. (1)Argue your own position on the value of boredom. Take a clear side. Back it with specific evidence you know from reading, experience, or observation. Explain how that evidence supports your reasoning, and write in clear, correct English.
Prompt 2

What Convenience Costs

A retired cabinetmaker (a fictional speaker invented for this prompt) told a high school graduating class: 'Every tool that saves you effort also takes something from you. Before you hand a job to a machine, ask what the job was teaching you.'

  1. (1)Argue your own position on the extent to which tools that make tasks easier take away valuable skills or experiences. Take a clear side. Back it with specific evidence you know from reading, experience, or observation. Explain how that evidence supports your reasoning, and write in clear, correct English.

Scored examples

Two responses per prompt — one near the top of the rubric, one in the middle — with every point accounted for. The mid response earns its score through the mistakes students actually make.

The Case for Boredom · high-scoring response6/6

Most adults treat a bored teenager as a problem to solve, immediately offering a chore, a lesson, or a screen. The writers who defend boredom are right that this habit costs us something. But boredom is not valuable automatically; it becomes valuable only when a person has the freedom to act on it. Boredom is a signal that the present is not enough, and its worth depends on whether we answer the signal or silence it.

Boredom is uncomfortable enough to push people into action, and that discomfort is where its value starts. In a 2014 study at the University of Virginia, researchers left people alone in a bare room for up to fifteen minutes. Their only options were to think or to press a button that delivered a mild electric shock. About two-thirds of the men and a quarter of the women shocked themselves at least once, even though they had said earlier that they would pay money to avoid that shock. They preferred physical pain to sitting quietly with their own thoughts, which reveals how powerful the urge to escape boredom really is. The same urge that sent them to the button sends a bored kid to build a fort or a bored adult to start a project. Boredom functions like hunger: it is unpleasant precisely so that we will do something about it.

When an easy distraction does not cut off that push, it often turns into creativity. Psychologists Sandi Mann and Rebekah Cadman had one group copy numbers out of a phone book before a creative task: listing uses for a pair of plastic cups. The bored group came up with more ideas than a group that skipped the dull task. The tedium sent their minds wandering, and wandering minds make strange connections. I saw the same thing the summer our internet was out for three weeks. I finally finished the comic I had abandoned twice. I had not suddenly become more disciplined; I had simply run out of easier distractions.

This is why the endless feed is a real loss and not a harmless habit. A phone does not actually cure boredom. It interrupts the signal before the signal can accomplish anything. When I scroll in a waiting room, I trade the restlessness that might have become an idea for a stream of other people's ideas. The discomfort ends, but so does the push.

Still, praising boredom without limits would be naive. A worker on an assembly line who repeats the same motion for ten hours is bored too, and nothing about that boredom is creative. It does not lead to a novel or an invention, because the worker cannot leave the line to follow a restless thought. Boredom only pays off for people with some freedom to respond to it. For everyone else, boredom is a symptom of work that wastes their abilities. The defenders of boredom quietly assume a person with time and choices, like a student on summer break, not someone working a double shift.

So the right response to boredom is neither to fear it nor to worship it. For people who can use it, we should protect it: put the phone down and let a slow afternoon stay slow. For people who cannot, we should treat boredom as a complaint worth hearing. For them boredom is not a gift but evidence that something in their circumstances needs to change.

How it scored

1/1A — Earned. The thesis takes a clear, arguable position (boredom has value only when a person is free to act on it) and answers the prompt's actual question about the value of boredom.
4/4B — Earned in full. Every claim rests on specific evidence: the 2014 Virginia shock study, the Mann and Cadman phone-book experiment, and a concrete personal example. The commentary explains the mechanism each time, arguing that boredom pushes like hunger, that the push becomes creativity, and that the phone interrupts it. Because each paragraph depends on the previous one, the reasoning develops rather than accumulating as a list.
1/1C — Earned. The assembly-line paragraph does more than mention an objection. It identifies the hidden assumption in the prompt's position, that the bored person has time and choices, and incorporates that limitation into the thesis itself. The conclusion follows through with a different recommendation for each group, so the complexity shapes the entire essay rather than a single sentence.
The Case for Boredom · mid-scoring response3/6

In today's world, people are never bored because they always have their phones. However, boredom is actually a good thing. Boredom is good because it makes people more creative, it gives them time to reflect, and it teaches them patience.

First, boredom makes people more creative. Studies show that when people are bored they come up with more creative ideas. This is because their brain has nothing to do so it starts making up its own ideas. For example, Isaac Newton discovered gravity when he was sitting under a tree with nothing to do and an apple fell on his head. If Newton had a phone, he would have been scrolling and he never would have noticed the apple. This shows that boredom leads to creativity.

Second, boredom gives people time to reflect. Last summer my family went on a road trip to Colorado. It was a nine hour drive and my phone died after the first two hours. At first I was really bored and annoyed. I looked out the window at the fields and then the mountains. We stopped at a gas station in Kansas and got snacks. By the time we got to Denver I had been thinking for a long time. This shows that boredom gives you time to reflect on your life.

Third, boredom teaches patience. In the past people had to wait for things. They had to wait for letters to come in the mail and wait for their favorite show to come on TV. Now everything is instant and people get mad if a video takes five seconds to load. Being bored teaches people to be patient, which is an important skill in life.

Some people might say that boredom is bad because it makes people unhappy. But this is wrong because boredom always leads to something good in the end.

In conclusion, boredom is valuable because it makes people creative, gives them time to reflect, and teaches patience. People should never use their phones when they are bored, because they are taking away something valuable from themselves.

How it scored

1/1A — Earned. The thesis is defensible and answers the prompt. However, it is a three-reason list, which sets up three disconnected paragraphs instead of one developing argument.
2/4B — Two points. Some evidence is specific, but 'studies show' identifies no actual study, and the Newton anecdote presents a popular legend as historical fact. The road trip paragraph narrates the drive without ever revealing what the writer reflected on, so it proves nothing about reflection. The patience paragraph offers generalizations rather than evidence. Each paragraph concludes with 'this shows' instead of explaining the connection, and the paragraphs could be rearranged without loss, so no line of reasoning emerges.
0/1C — Not earned. The opposing view receives one sentence and is dismissed with 'always.' The concluding recommendation that people should 'never' use phones when bored extends far beyond anything the evidence supports, and this kind of overclaiming is the opposite of the nuance Row C rewards.
What Convenience Costs · high-scoring response5/6

A GPS will get you to a new restaurant without one wrong turn. It will also guarantee that you never learn where the restaurant actually is. The cabinetmaker is correct. When a tool takes over a task, it also takes over the practice that built the skill, and the skill fades. Navigation, note-taking, and even memory show how this works, and how quietly it happens.

The clearest proof comes from navigation. To earn a license, London taxi drivers must memorize roughly 25,000 streets, a test called the Knowledge that takes years to pass. In 2000, neuroscientist Eleanor Maguire found that experienced cabbies had a larger posterior hippocampus, a part of the brain used for spatial memory, than people who did not drive taxis. For the cabbies, the skill the cabinetmaker warns about was not some vague virtue; it showed up physically in their brains. Later research on ordinary drivers found that people who rely heavily on GPS tend to perform worse on spatial-memory tasks. The device does not simply steer for us. By holding the map, it removes the exercise that builds a mental map.

The same trade happens in school, where the effort is supposed to be the point. In 2014, Pam Mueller and Daniel Oppenheimer found that students who took notes on laptops did worse on conceptual questions than students who wrote by hand. The laptop users typed lectures almost word for word. Handwriting is too slow for that, so the hand note-takers had to decide what mattered and put it in their own words. The laptop made note-taking easier by cutting out the exact step that produced learning. This is what the cabinetmaker means by asking what the job was teaching you. Taking notes was teaching students to sort ideas, and the faster tool skipped the lesson.

Even memory itself can be handed off. Psychologist Linda Henkel led students on a museum tour and had them photograph some objects and simply look at others. The next day they remembered fewer details about the objects they had photographed. Once the camera preserved the image, the mind apparently stopped working to remember it. The pattern matches the GPS and the laptop. Each tool promises to help us keep something, and each one lets us stop doing the work of keeping it.

Some people argue that tools free up time for more important things. But the minutes a GPS saves on a drive are small, and the sense of direction it costs took years to build. Most of us do not spend that saved time on anything better.

Before handing a job to a machine, we should do what the cabinetmaker suggests and ask what the job was teaching us. Convenience is never entirely free. We pay for it with abilities we do not notice we are losing until the battery dies.

How it scored

1/1A — Earned. The thesis takes a definite side and identifies the mechanism it will defend: the tool takes over the practice that originally built the skill.
4/4B — Earned in full. Three specific, correctly attributed examples (the London taxi drivers, the laptop note-takers, and the museum photographs) each come with commentary explaining how the tool removes the effort that develops the skill. The paragraph on Henkel's study explicitly connects all three, so the reasoning builds instead of repeating.
0/1C — Not earned. The counterargument receives three sentences and a quick dismissal, and the essay never confronts the strongest case against its position. Some tools eliminate pure drudgery; a washing machine saves hours of scrubbing that taught nobody anything valuable. Exploring where convenience costs a skill and where it does not would have qualified the thesis and probably earned this point.
What Convenience Costs · mid-scoring response3/6

Technology has made life much easier, but it has also made people lazy. I agree with the cabinetmaker that tools that save effort take something away from us, because people today cannot do basic things without technology.

One example is GPS. My older brother cannot drive anywhere without his phone telling him where to go. One time his phone died and he got lost going to his friends house even though he had been there before. If he had learned the roads himself he would have known how to get there. This shows that GPS takes away people's sense of direction.

Another example is calculators. Kids today use calculators for everything and cannot do simple math in their heads. My grandpa can add up a whole receipt in his head but most teenagers would have to take out their phones. This proves that calculators make people worse at math.

Also, a study showed that people who write notes by hand remember more than people who type them. This is because writing by hand is better for your brain. Schools should make students write their notes by hand.

Technology is also making people lose skills like cooking and writing letters. In the old days people cooked every meal from scratch and wrote long letters to each other. Now people order food on apps and send texts with emojis. People are losing important skills that they used to have.

Some people say technology is good because it saves time. But people just waste the time they save on social media, so it does not matter.

In conclusion, tools that make tasks easier take away valuable skills. People should try to do things the hard way more often so they do not lose their skills.

How it scored

1/1A — Earned. Agreeing that tools take away skills because people become dependent on them is a defensible position that responds directly to the prompt.
2/4B — Two points. The brother's GPS story is specific, but one person getting lost cannot demonstrate that GPS takes away everyone's sense of direction. The calculator example compares the grandfather with teenagers but never explains how the tool prevented the skill from developing. The note-taking study is unidentified, and 'better for your brain' substitutes for the actual mechanism. The cooking and letter-writing paragraph is entirely general, and the paragraphs function as a list rather than a line of reasoning.
0/1C — Not earned. The counterargument is dismissed with a sweeping generalization that everyone wastes saved time. The essay never considers whether some conveniences are worth their cost, so the position remains flat and absolute.

Where points die

Writing a 'both sides' thesis: 'There are pros and cons to boredom.' Row A requires a position, and an argument essay is not a balanced survey of opinions. Qualifying is welcome: 'Boredom is valuable only when people are free to act on it' is a genuine position, while refusing to choose is not. Commit to a side, then demonstrate exactly where it stops being true.

Claiming more than you can prove with 'always,' 'never,' and 'everyone.' One brother lost without GPS proves something about dependence, not about every driver. Match the size of your claim to your evidence, and use 'often' or 'when' at the point where your evidence runs out.

Naming evidence, then ending with 'This shows that…' and repeating the thesis. This habit is a common reason essays stall at 2 in Row B. After every example, explain the mechanism: what the example demonstrates, how it works, and why that supports your claim. 'Taxi drivers who memorize streets develop the brain region for spatial memory, so a tool that holds the map removes that exercise' is commentary. 'This shows GPS is bad' is not.

Using vague or false evidence: 'studies show,' or a legend told as fact. Specific means who, when, and what was discovered: 'In 2014, Mueller and Oppenheimer found that laptop note-takers performed worse on conceptual questions.' If you cannot remember exact numbers, describe the finding without inventing statistics. Citing a real study as a finding is fine even if later research disputes it; readers reward correct attribution, not settled science. Popular stories such as the apple falling on Newton's head are legends, and readers recognize them, so a false example damages your credibility.

Arguing against a different or bigger target than the prompt names. If the prompt concerns tools that make tasks easier, do not drift into arguing that technology is ruining society. If the prompt asks about the value of boredom, an essay about why phones are addictive has changed the question. Reread the prompt's central phrase before each body paragraph and confirm that the paragraph still answers that question.

Chasing sophistication with big words, a quotation, or a dramatic last line. Row C rewards thinking that runs through the entire essay. The most reliable route is a strong opposing view that you genuinely work through. Grant the washing machine its point, then use it to sharpen your thesis: tools cost us when the effort was the lesson, and liberate us when the effort was only labor. If you have time for just one sophisticated move, make it this one.

Score your own response

0 / 6

Be the harshest reader in the room: award a point only when your response does what the line says, on the page — not what you meant to write.