Skip to content
AP English Language and Composition · Claims and Evidence

Burden of proof

Burden of proof appears in 3 reviewed AP English Language and Composition questions and sits in Claims and Evidence. Below are worked examples showing exactly how the exam tests it, with the answer marked and every distractor explained.

How Burden of proof is tested

Example 1Medium
Read the following passage and answer the question. The minimum wage, the overtime threshold, the right to organize, the safety regulation, the anti-discrimination statute — each was opposed, at the time of its passage, with the same argument: it would destroy jobs, cripple industry, and undermine the American economy. Each was passed over those objections. And in each case, the predicted catastrophe did not materialize. The minimum wage did not eliminate entry-level employment. The overtime threshold did not bankrupt small businesses. The right to organize did not make American industry uncompetitive. The safety regulation did not halt production. The anti-discrimination statute did not produce the racial conflict its opponents predicted. The economy absorbed each reform, adapted, and grew. This historical pattern does not prove that every proposed labor reform will succeed. But it does shift the burden of proof: given the consistent failure of catastrophic predictions, those who predict catastrophe should be required to explain why this time is different. The historical catalog of reforms and their opponents' failed predictions serves primarily to
  1. Ademonstrate that the American economy is essentially immune to the disruptive effects of any new regulation, however extensive
  2. Bargue that because past predictions of catastrophe proved wrong, every future labor reform will succeed without any negative consequences
  3. Cdraw an unfavorable comparison between labor protections adopted in the United States and those enacted by other industrialized nations
  4. Destablish a pattern of failed catastrophic predictions that shifts the burden of proof onto those who now predict catastrophe from reformCorrect

Why D is right

The catalog establishes a pattern: opponents of labor reforms consistently predict catastrophe, and the predictions consistently prove wrong. This pattern does not guarantee future success but shifts the burden of proof: anyone predicting catastrophe from a new reform must explain why the historical pattern will not hold.
Why the other 3 choices miss
A
Incorrect because the passage says the economy 'absorbed' and adapted to reforms, not that it is immune to any regulation whatsoever.
B
Incorrect because the passage explicitly states the pattern 'does not prove that every proposed reform will succeed.'
C
Incorrect because the passage focuses entirely on American historical patterns and never draws an international comparison.

Studied alongside

Other concepts from Claims and Evidence.