Skip to content
AP English Language and Composition · Claims and Evidence

Concession and rebuttal

Concession and rebuttal appears in 3 reviewed AP English Language and Composition questions and sits in Claims and Evidence. Below are worked examples showing exactly how the exam tests it, with the answer marked and every distractor explained.

How Concession and rebuttal is tested

Example 1Medium
Read the following passage and answer the question. "Opponents of rent control argue that it reduces housing supply by discouraging new construction and incentivizing landlords to convert rental units to condominiums. This is a real effect, documented in peer-reviewed research. Acknowledging it is not a concession; it is the beginning of an honest argument. The honest argument is this: rent control in its current form is a flawed tool being used to address an emergency that better tools have failed to address. When the choice is between a flawed solution and no solution, the flawed solution wins — not because it is good but because the emergency is real and the people in it cannot wait for the perfect policy to be designed, debated, passed, funded, and implemented." The author's acknowledgment that rent control's drawbacks are 'documented in peer-reviewed research' primarily functions as:
  1. AEvidence that peer-reviewed research on housing policy is inherently biased toward landlord and developer interests
  2. BA signal that the author has quietly abandoned support for rent control and now favors market-based alternatives
  3. CA concession so damaging that it fatally undermines the author's overall case for keeping rent control in place
  4. DA strategic move that builds credibility before reframing the drawbacks within an emergency argumentCorrect

Why D is right

By acknowledging the peer-reviewed evidence against rent control before making the case for it, the author demonstrates intellectual honesty, which builds ethos and defuses the most powerful objection. The passage explicitly says 'Acknowledging it is not a concession; it is the beginning of an honest argument,' signaling that the acknowledgment is tactical: it clears the air so the author can advance the emergency-based argument on stronger ground.
Why the other 3 choices miss
A
The passage cites the peer-reviewed research as credible, not as biased, and never claims it serves landlord or developer interests.
B
The passage never wavers in its ultimate position, nor does it endorse market-based alternatives; the acknowledgment of drawbacks is part of the argument's structure, not a reversal of position.
C
The author explicitly rejects the idea that this acknowledgment is a concession. The passage continues to support rent control on emergency grounds, so the acknowledgment does not undermine the argument.

Studied alongside

Other concepts from Claims and Evidence.