Read the following passage, then answer the question.
The proposal to replace human court reporters with automated transcription software presents itself as a modernization. In fact, it is a gamble with due process. Court reporters do not merely transcribe; they interrupt. When a witness mumbles, the court reporter asks for clarification. When two speakers talk simultaneously, the reporter requests that the record reflect who said what. When an attorney misstates a previous answer, the reporter can read back the accurate version. Automated transcription software does none of these things. It records what it hears with impressive accuracy — the leading product claims 94% word recognition — but accuracy of recording is not accuracy of record. A 94% accurate transcription of an inaudible exchange is a precisely rendered falsehood. The six percent error rate, averaged across a typical eight-hour proceeding, produces approximately 11,520 incorrectly transcribed words per day. Among those words may be the ones that determine whether a defendant is convicted or acquitted, whether a contract is enforceable, whether a custody arrangement stands. The question is not whether the technology works. The question is whether 94% is good enough when the remaining six percent includes someone's freedom.
The author's calculation of 11,520 incorrectly transcribed words per day serves to
- Aargue that human court reporters never make transcription errors, since the passage praises their ability to interrupt and clarify testimony
- Bprove that automated transcription will inevitably cause wrongful convictions in every case where the software is used
- Cdemonstrate the author's mathematical or statistical skill in order to establish credibility with a skeptical audience
- Dconvert the abstract six percent error rate into a concrete daily figure that makes the scale of potential harm vivid and alarmingCorrect
Why D is right
A '6% error rate' sounds manageable in the abstract, but 11,520 incorrect words per day makes the same statistic alarming. The calculation converts a percentage into a concrete quantity, forcing the reader to confront the actual volume of errors and their potential consequences in legal proceedings.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- Incorrect because the passage does not claim human reporters are error-free; it argues that reporters perform active functions (interrupting, clarifying, reading back) that prevent certain types of errors that software cannot.
- B
- Incorrect because the author argues the errors create unacceptable risk ('may be the ones that determine'), not that wrongful convictions are inevitable; the claim is about probability and stakes, not certainty.
- C
- Incorrect because the calculation serves the argument (making the error rate vivid), not the author's self-presentation; the math is simple and serves a rhetorical purpose, not a credentialing one.