Skip to content
AP English Language and Composition · Claims and Evidence

Cross passage

Cross passage appears in 8 reviewed AP English Language and Composition questions and sits in Claims and Evidence. Below are worked examples showing exactly how the exam tests it, with the answer marked and every distractor explained.

How Cross passage is tested

Example 1Harder
Read the following passage, then answer the question. Passage 1 (from a memoir about competitive swimming, 2011): The pool, for those who train seriously in it, is not a place of pleasure. It is a place of repetition, discomfort, and the precise measurement of incremental improvement. Every practice session ends with the same calculation: was I faster today? By how much? What broke down? My coach believed that technique was everything — that if the stroke was right, the speed would follow. I believed him and still do, though I also learned that believing in technique does not protect you from the days when everything is wrong and your body simply refuses to cooperate with your mind. Passage 2 (from a sports psychology article, 2013): Elite swimmers consistently report that the mental dimension of performance — specifically, the ability to maintain focus and composure under competitive pressure — is as determinative of race outcomes as physical preparation. The 'everything is technique' coaching philosophy, while effective for skill acquisition in training, tends to produce athletes who are technically excellent but psychologically fragile under the specific conditions of competition, where self-monitoring of technique can itself become a source of performance anxiety. Which of the following best describes the relationship between the swimmer's experience in Passage 1 and the research claim in Passage 2?
  1. APassage 1 fully supports Passage 2, because the swimmer explicitly reports experiencing performance anxiety during competition
  2. BPassage 1 partially illustrates Passage 2's claim, because the swimmer acknowledges that belief in technique does not prevent days when the body does not cooperateCorrect
  3. CThe two passages are unrelated because Passage 1 describes training while Passage 2 addresses competition
  4. DPassage 1 contradicts Passage 2, because the swimmer describes technique as the only determinant of performance

Why B is right

The swimmer in Passage 1 believes in technique but acknowledges 'days when everything is wrong and the body refuses to cooperate with the mind' — a phrase suggesting that technique-focused training does not fully address the mental-physical disconnects that Passage 2's research identifies. This is partial illustration, not full support or contradiction.
Why the other 3 choices miss
A
The swimmer does not explicitly report performance anxiety during competition; the acknowledgment of bad training days is more oblique than that.
C
The swimmer's point about technique not protecting against breakdowns is directly relevant to Passage 2's claim about technique-focused training producing psychologically fragile athletes.
D
The swimmer qualifies the technique belief by acknowledging its limits; this is not a full contradiction of Passage 2.
Example 2Medium
Read the following passage, then answer the question. Passage 1 (philosopher of science, 1998): Science's authority in modern democratic societies rests on an implicit social contract: scientists produce reliable knowledge through rigorous methods, and citizens trust that knowledge even without fully understanding the methods. This contract is not inherently stable. When scientists disagree publicly, when research is funded by interested parties, or when scientific consensus contradicts economic interests of powerful constituencies, the trust is eroded — not because science has failed but because the social conditions that made the contract sustainable have changed. Passage 2 (science communication researcher, 2015): The 'deficit model' of science communication — the idea that public distrust of science results from a deficit of scientific literacy that can be remedied by more and better information — is empirically wrong. Research consistently shows that increased scientific literacy does not increase trust in scientific institutions among people who distrust them for other reasons. Trust in science is not primarily a cognitive phenomenon; it is a social one. People trust scientists from their own communities, who speak their language, and who are visible in their daily lives — not scientists whose authority is credentialed by institutions they have reason to distrust. Based on both passages, which of the following conclusions is most directly supported?
  1. AScientific consensus is more trustworthy than individual scientists' opinions because it aggregates many experts' independent judgments
  2. BPublic trust in science depends on social relationships and institutional conditions, not on the inherent reliability of scientific methodsCorrect
  3. CThe solution to declining public trust in science is to improve scientific literacy through better public education and outreach
  4. DScientists who engage directly with public audiences undermine their own credibility by communicating outside peer-reviewed channels

Why B is right

Passage 1 argues that trust depends on social contract conditions (agreement public, funding independence, etc.). Passage 2 argues that trust is social, not cognitive. Together, both passages converge on the conclusion that public trust in science depends on social relationships and institutional conditions, not simply on the reliability of scientific methods.
Why the other 3 choices miss
A
Neither passage discusses aggregating many experts' independent judgments as a basis for trustworthiness.
C
Passage 2 explicitly refutes this by saying the 'deficit model' is 'empirically wrong'; Passage 1 does not support it either.
D
Neither passage addresses scientists who communicate publicly as undermining their credibility.

Studied alongside

Other concepts from Claims and Evidence.