Skip to content
AP English Language and Composition · Claims and Evidence

Cross passage agreement

Cross passage agreement appears in 5 reviewed AP English Language and Composition questions and sits in Claims and Evidence. Below are worked examples showing exactly how the exam tests it, with the answer marked and every distractor explained.

How Cross passage agreement is tested

Example 1Medium
Read the following passage, then answer the question. Passage 1 (food policy advocate, 2014): The organic food movement has made an important cultural contribution by shifting consumer attention to the conditions under which food is produced. But it has also made a problematic economic one: organic certification has become a premium-market strategy that prices out precisely the consumers most harmed by industrial agriculture. The communities living near factory farms and confined animal feeding operations are rarely the communities buying organic produce at whole food stores. Healthy food has become a luxury good at exactly the moment when it should be a public health priority. Passage 2 (agricultural economist, 2016): The critique of organic food as a luxury good is partially accurate but misidentifies the cause. Organic food is expensive not because of organic farming practices per se, but because of the absence of the subsidies that make conventionally produced food artificially cheap. The solution is not to abandon organic standards but to restructure agricultural subsidies — redirecting the billions currently supporting commodity crops toward smaller, diversified, and organic operations. The price gap between organic and conventional would largely disappear if the subsidy playing field were leveled. On which point would the authors of both passages most likely agree?
  1. AConsumer purchasing decisions, more than policy or subsidy reform, are the most effective lever for improving public health outcomes
  2. BOrganic certification should be eliminated because it has failed to improve food access for low-income communities
  3. CAgricultural subsidies are the primary cause of the health disparities associated with industrial food production
  4. DThe current food system creates inequitable access to healthy food, a problem that requires structural interventionCorrect

Why D is right

Passage 1 argues that healthy food has become a luxury at a time when it should be a public health priority — implying a need for structural change. Passage 2 argues that subsidy restructuring is needed to correct the price gap. Both agree that the current situation is inequitable and requires structural intervention.
Why the other 3 choices miss
A
Neither passage emphasizes consumer choice; both focus on structural and policy-level interventions.
B
Neither passage calls for eliminating organic certification; Passage 2 explicitly defends organic standards.
C
Passage 1 does not identify subsidies as the primary cause; it critiques the cultural and economic dynamics of the organic movement itself.
Example 2Medium
Read the following passage, then answer the question. Passage 1 (from a coaching memoir, 2010): The most important thing I ever learned about coaching came from watching players who had failed — not the players who failed once and recovered, but the ones who failed and did not recover. The difference, in almost every case, was not physical. It was whether the player could construct a narrative about the failure that left room for a next attempt. Players who explained failure as evidence of permanent inadequacy stopped trying; players who explained it as information about what needed to change tried again. My job, I eventually understood, was not to prevent failure but to teach players how to think about failure afterward. Passage 2 (from a sports psychology research review, 2012): The literature on attribution theory in athletic performance consistently shows that athletes who attribute failure to stable, internal, uncontrollable factors (e.g., 'I'm not naturally talented enough') show decreased motivation and performance in subsequent attempts, while those who attribute failure to unstable, controllable factors (e.g., 'I didn't prepare well enough') show maintained or improved motivation. This finding is robust across sports, age groups, and performance levels. It does not imply that all failures can be reframed positively; it implies that the causal story an athlete tells is itself a performance variable. The coach in Passage 1 and the researchers in Passage 2 arrive at which shared conclusion?
  1. AThe explanatory narrative an athlete constructs about failure is causally relevant to subsequent motivation and performanceCorrect
  2. BAthletes who fail repeatedly should be identified early and redirected toward alternative sports that better match their natural capabilities
  3. CCoaches are primarily responsible for teaching athletes how to manage failure through explicit, structured psychological instruction
  4. DPhysical talent is less important than mental resilience in determining long-term athletic success and achievement

Why A is right

The coach concluded that 'how players thought about failure' determined whether they tried again. The researchers found that 'the causal story an athlete tells is itself a performance variable.' Both agree that the narrative/attribution about failure matters causally for subsequent performance.
Why the other 3 choices miss
B
Neither source suggests redirecting repeatedly failing athletes; both suggest the failure narrative can be changed.
C
The coach does suggest this is his job, but the researchers do not endorse explicit coaching instruction; the shared conclusion is narrower — about attribution, not about who is responsible for teaching it.
D
Neither source makes the comparative claim about talent vs. resilience; both focus specifically on how failure is explained.

Studied alongside

Other concepts from Claims and Evidence.