Skip to content
AP English Language and Composition · Claims and Evidence

Definitional argument

Definitional argument appears in 8 reviewed AP English Language and Composition questions and sits in Claims and Evidence. Below are worked examples showing exactly how the exam tests it, with the answer marked and every distractor explained.

How Definitional argument is tested

Example 1Medium
Read the following passage, then answer the question. The proposal to install surveillance cameras in every classroom is defended as a safety measure, but safety is a concept elastic enough to justify almost anything. The cameras will not prevent a crisis — no camera has ever stopped a bullet. They will produce a recording of the crisis, which is useful for investigation but useless for protection. What the cameras will prevent, with documented reliability, is spontaneity. A 2022 study on classroom surveillance found that teachers in surveilled classrooms were 34% less likely to deviate from prescribed curricula and 41% less likely to engage in improvisational discussion. Students in those classrooms reported feeling 'watched' — a sensation that, according to the study's authors, produced behavioral conformity but not actual safety. The cameras will create an environment in which everyone behaves as though they are being observed, because they are. This is not safety. This is obedience, and the two should not be confused. The author's argument relies primarily on which strategy?
  1. AAppealing to teachers' emotional discomfort with constant observation, treating their subjective sense of being watched as sufficient proof that surveillance itself is harmful.
  2. BArguing that the cost of installing and maintaining cameras in every classroom outweighs any safety benefit the district hopes to gain from the program.
  3. CCiting legal precedents and privacy statutes that prohibit continuous visual surveillance of students in publicly funded educational settings without parental consent.
  4. DRedefining 'safety' against 'obedience' and citing empirical study data to argue cameras produce compliance rather than actual protection from harm.Correct

Why D is right

The author's central strategy is definitional: separating 'safety' (prevention of harm) from 'obedience' (behavioral conformity under observation), then supporting that distinction with the cited study's empirical data showing cameras reduce spontaneity and induce a feeling of being watched without actually preventing crises.
Why the other 3 choices miss
A
Incorrect because the argument relies on research data and definitional reasoning, not on teachers' subjective feelings of discomfort about being observed.
B
Incorrect because cost is never mentioned in the passage; the argument concerns what cameras actually accomplish (obedience) versus what they claim to accomplish (safety), not their price.
C
Incorrect because the passage cites no legal precedents or statutes; its evidence is an empirical study, and its reasoning is definitional (safety vs. obedience).
Example 2Medium
Read the following passage and answer the question. "Before we can reform the criminal legal system, we must name what it is. It is not broken. 'Broken' implies that it once worked and has since malfunctioned — that there is some golden era of American justice to which we might return. There is no such era. The system was designed, from its earliest incarnations, to control and contain Black and Indigenous people, to protect property over persons, to render the poor legible to the state while leaving the wealthy opaque. What appears to reformers as malfunction is, to the communities bearing the weight of it, consistent and predictable performance. The system does not need to be fixed. It needs to be reimagined." The author's opening statement — 'Before we can reform the criminal legal system, we must name what it is' — establishes which structural purpose for the passage?
  1. AIt introduces a concession, acknowledging that reform advocates are correct before the author argues for a more radical alternative
  2. BIt frames the passage as a definitional argument, positioning accurate naming as the necessary precondition for meaningful actionCorrect
  3. CIt identifies the passage's audience as criminal justice reformers and signals that the author will critique their methods
  4. DIt announces a two-part essay structure in which the first part names the system and the second part proposes policy solutions

Why B is right

The opening sentence is a definitional frame: it asserts that correct naming must precede reform. Everything that follows is an argument about what the system actually is (not 'broken' but functioning as designed), which is a definitional argument. The structural logic is: define first, act second. The passage fulfills the definitional half; policy prescriptions are not its goal. This is not primarily a concession, audience identification, or structural announcement.
Why the other 3 choices miss
A
The passage does not concede that reformers are correct. It challenges the reform framework by arguing that 'reform' misdiagnoses the system's fundamental nature.
C
While reformers are an implied audience, the sentence's primary structural function is definitional, not audience identification. The passage is about what the system is, not about how reformers conduct themselves.
D
The passage does not propose policy solutions. The definitional argument ('name what it is') is the entire content; the closing 'reimagined' is a call, not a developed policy framework.

Studied alongside

Other concepts from Claims and Evidence.