Read the following passage, then answer the question.
Frederick Douglass, speaking before a crowd in Rochester, New York, on July 5, 1852, confronted his audience with characteristic directness: 'This Fourth July is yours, not mine. You may rejoice, I must mourn. To drag a man in fetters into the grand illuminated temple of liberty, and call upon him to join you in joyous anthems, were inhuman mockery and sacrilegious irony.' He did not permit his listeners the comfortable distance of abstraction. The American promise, Douglass insisted, was not a shared inheritance but a contested claim — one that the enslaved had been denied through systematic violence and legal artifice. His rhetoric operated simultaneously on multiple registers: legal, moral, and emotional. He cited scripture, invoked the Declaration of Independence, and catalogued the atrocities of the domestic slave trade, moving his audience through admiration, guilt, and finally, an unavoidable confrontation with national hypocrisy.
The author's reference to Douglass's rhetoric operating 'on multiple registers' primarily serves to...
- Asuggest that Douglass's argument was inconsistent because it drew on legal, moral, and emotional sources that could not be reconciled
- Bshow that Douglass strategically appealed to his audience's legal, moral, and emotional commitments all at onceCorrect
- Cdemonstrate that Douglass prioritized emotional appeal over legal and logical argumentation in his speech
- Dimply that Douglass was uncertain which single mode of persuasion would be most effective with his audience
Why B is right
The phrase 'multiple registers' refers to Douglass's deliberate layering of legal citations, moral argument, and emotional appeal to reach his audience through every possible avenue of persuasion. The author frames this as strategic, not inconsistent or uncertain.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- The passage does not suggest inconsistency; rather, it presents Douglass's use of legal, moral, and emotional sources together as a strength of his rhetoric, not a flaw.
- C
- The passage explicitly lists legal and moral registers alongside the emotional one, so claiming emotional appeal was prioritized over the others misreads the passage.
- D
- The author describes Douglass's approach as deliberate and purposeful, not uncertain or exploratory.