Read the following passage.
"The question is not whether we should teach evolution in schools. The question is not whether we should teach creationism. The question — the only question worth asking — is whether we trust our children enough to present them with two competing accounts of their origin and allow them the dignity of choosing. The parent who shields a child from opposing ideas does not protect the child; he imprisons him in the parent's own certainty. The teacher who presents only one theory does not educate; she indoctrinates. And the society that fears its own children's judgment has already confessed to a failure more profound than any pedagogical dispute: it has confessed that its ideas cannot survive scrutiny."
The enthymeme in the final sentence — that a society fearing children's judgment has confessed its ideas cannot survive scrutiny — relies on which unstated premise?
- APublic education must remain neutral by excluding all forms of religious instruction
- BChildren's fresh perspective makes their judgment more reliable than that of adults
- CReligious and scientific explanations of human origins are fundamentally incompatible
- DIdeas that are genuinely strong need no protection from competing viewsCorrect
Why D is right
The enthymeme's stated elements are: (1) society fears children encountering competing ideas, and (2) this fear constitutes a confession that its ideas cannot survive scrutiny. The unstated premise linking these is: ideas that are genuinely strong do not need protection from competition — they can survive scrutiny. Without this premise, the conclusion does not follow.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- Incorrect because the passage argues for intellectual openness rather than secularism; it advocates presenting multiple viewpoints, not excluding religious ones.
- B
- Incorrect because the argument does not depend on children having more reliable judgment than adults, only that ideas strong enough to be true can withstand examination by any audience.
- C
- Incorrect because the passage advocates presenting both perspectives, not declaring them incompatible.