Read the following passage and answer the question.
The enthusiasm for "coding boot camps" as an alternative to traditional higher education reflects a broader cultural tendency to reduce education to job training. These programs promise to transform anyone into a software developer in twelve to sixteen weeks, and their marketing materials feature testimonials from graduates who tripled their salaries. What they rarely mention is the attrition: many programs report completion rates below 60%. They do not mention that the skills taught become obsolete within three to five years as programming languages and frameworks evolve. They do not mention that the mid-career developers who struggle most in the job market are precisely those who learned one narrow technical stack without the broader analytical foundation that a traditional computer science education provides. The boot camp model works—for a while, for some people. But "for a while, for some people" is a poor foundation for national workforce policy.
The sentence "The boot camp model works—for a while, for some people" is an example of which rhetorical technique?
- AHyperbole, deliberately exaggerating the failures of boot camps to strengthen the argument
- BAd hominem attack, discrediting the character of boot camp advocates rather than addressing their arguments
- CFalse analogy, comparing the boot camp model to an unrelated educational model with fundamentally different goals
- DConcession followed by qualification, acknowledging limited merit before restricting the scope of that acknowledgmentCorrect
Why D is right
The sentence concedes that boot camps 'work' (acknowledgment of limited validity), then immediately qualifies that concession with 'for a while, for some people,' restricting both the duration and the population for whom the model succeeds. This technique demonstrates fairness while ultimately undermining the broad claims made by boot camp advocates.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- Incorrect because the sentence actually understates boot camp failures by conceding they do work in limited circumstances; hyperbole would involve exaggeration, not measured qualification.
- B
- Incorrect because the passage critiques the boot camp model, curricula, and outcomes—not the character or motives of its advocates; this is substantive argument, not personal attack.
- C
- Incorrect because no analogy is made in this sentence; the author directly evaluates the boot camp model without comparing it to something else.
Read the following passage, then answer the question.
The argument for universal pre-kindergarten cannot rest on sentiment alone. Those who advocate for early childhood education because 'children deserve the best start' are making an ethical claim that, however admirable, fails to persuade legislators who think in fiscal years rather than developmental stages. The Perry Preschool Study offers firmer ground. Tracking participants over four decades, the study found that children who attended a high-quality preschool program earned, on average, $20,800 more per year by age 40, were 46% less likely to have served jail time, and were 20% more likely to hold steady employment. The return on investment was calculated at $7 to $12 for every dollar spent. These are not the numbers of a social experiment; they are the numbers of a sound investment. When we frame early education as a cost rather than an expenditure, we have already lost the rhetorical battle. Reframing it as an investment — one with a documented, multi-decade return — transforms the conversation from charity to strategy.
The author includes the specific statistics from the Perry Preschool Study most likely in order to
- Acriticize legislators for prioritizing economic data over children's emotional and developmental well-being
- Bdemonstrate that the Perry Preschool Study is the most rigorous and widely cited longitudinal study in the history of educational research
- Cargue that every child who attends a high-quality preschool program will earn a significantly higher income as an adult
- Dshift the argument from moral sentiment to empirical evidence that appeals to fiscally minded decision-makersCorrect
Why D is right
The passage explicitly sets up a rhetorical problem — ethical arguments do not persuade fiscal legislators — and then presents the Perry Preschool statistics as the solution. The data (earnings, incarceration rates, ROI) is chosen to speak the language of legislators who 'think in fiscal years,' reframing the issue from moral sentiment to documented economic return.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- Incorrect because the author does not criticize legislators for prioritizing economic data over emotional or developmental concerns; the author instead strategically adopts economic framing to meet legislators on their own terms.
- B
- Incorrect because the author does not compare the study to other research or claim it is the most rigorous and widely cited study in the field's history; the statistics are included for their persuasive utility in a specific rhetorical context, not to rank the study's overall standing.
- C
- Incorrect because the author cites averages and percentages, not a guarantee for every individual child; the statistics describe group-level outcomes among study participants, not a prediction that each child who attends preschool will see a significantly higher income.
Read the following passage and answer the question.
A student is writing a research essay about the relationship between sleep deprivation and academic performance. She has collected the following sources:
Source 1: A Harvard Medical School study found that students who slept fewer than six hours per night had GPAs that were 0.45 points lower on average than students who slept seven or more hours, after controlling for study time, course difficulty, and socioeconomic background.
Source 2: The American Academy of Pediatrics recommends that high school start times be no earlier than 8:30 AM, noting that adolescent circadian rhythms naturally shift toward later sleep-wake cycles during puberty.
Source 3: A University of Minnesota study of 9,000 students across eight high schools found that schools that shifted start times from 7:25 AM to 8:30 AM saw a 4.5% increase in graduation rates and a measurable reduction in car accidents among teen drivers.
Source 4: A National Sleep Foundation survey found that 73% of high school students report sleeping fewer than the recommended eight hours on school nights, with homework, extracurricular activities, and screen time cited as primary causes.
Which source most directly challenges the assumption that sleep deprivation among students is primarily a matter of individual choice and personal discipline?
- ASource 1, because it establishes a correlation between sleep and academic performance
- BSource 2, because it identifies a biological mechanism (shifted circadian rhythms) that makes early sleep physiologically difficult for adolescents regardless of personal habitsCorrect
- CSource 4, because it identifies homework, extracurriculars, and screens as causes of sleep deprivation
- DSource 3, because it shows that later start times improve graduation rates
Why B is right
The assumption that sleep deprivation is a matter of 'individual choice and personal discipline' implies that students could simply choose to go to bed earlier. Source 2 directly challenges this by citing a biological mechanism: adolescent circadian rhythms shift during puberty, making earlier sleep physiologically difficult. This reframes the issue from personal behavior to biology, undermining the 'individual choice' assumption most directly.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- Incorrect because Source 1 establishes the consequences of sleep deprivation but does not address whether it results from individual choice or structural/biological factors.
- C
- Incorrect because while Source 4 identifies external causes, homework and extracurriculars could still be framed as individual choices (students could do less); Source 2's biological argument is harder to attribute to personal discipline.
- D
- Incorrect because Source 3 demonstrates the benefits of a structural change but does not directly explain why individual discipline is insufficient; it shows what works, not why the 'choice' framing is wrong.