Read the following passage, then answer the question.
The terms of the debate have been set by those who have the least to lose. 'We must balance environmental protection with economic growth,' say the senators whose districts contain the corporate headquarters and not the refineries, whose constituents breathe clean suburban air and not the petrochemical fog that hangs over Beaumont and Port Arthur and Cancer Alley. 'Balance' is the word of the comfortable. It assumes that both sides of the scale carry equal weight, that a quarterly earnings report and a child's respiratory system are commensurable quantities subject to negotiation. They are not. The child does not experience her asthma as one side of a balanced equation. She experiences it as an inability to breathe, which is not a metaphor, which is not a policy position, which is not negotiable. When we speak of balance, we must ask: balanced for whom? The shareholders are balanced. The child is gasping.
The juxtaposition of 'The shareholders are balanced. The child is gasping.' in the final sentences creates an effect that is
- Asentimentally manipulative, exploiting a sick child's suffering as an emotional shortcut that lets the writer dodge the underlying economic and policy arguments entirely
- Blogically fallacious, setting up a false dichotomy in which corporate profit and children's health are treated as the only two options, ignoring possible middle-ground policies
- Csharply polemical, juxtaposing the shareholders' comfort with the child's visceral suffering to expose 'balance' as an inadequate framework for environmental justiceCorrect
- Dobjectively descriptive, presenting the shareholders' and the child's situations as two neutral factual observations offered without any authorial judgment or commentary
Why C is right
The final juxtaposition places abstract financial comfort ('balanced') next to visceral physical suffering ('gasping') in two short, parallel sentences. This stark contrast is deliberately polemical — it forces the reader to confront the inadequacy of 'balance' as a framework by showing what it actually looks like for each party involved. The physical specificity of 'gasping' demolishes the abstraction of 'balance.'
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- Incorrect because the child is not introduced as a sentimental distraction; she is part of the argument's structure — the passage has already critiqued the concept of 'balance' analytically before using the child as a concrete illustration of its real-world implications.
- B
- Incorrect because the passage does not argue that profits and health cannot coexist; it argues that treating them as equally weighted in a 'balance' framework is inadequate because the consequences of each 'side' are not comparable.
- D
- Incorrect because the juxtaposition is heavily loaded with authorial judgment; 'gasping' is not a neutral observation but a deliberate rhetorical choice designed to make the reader feel the inadequacy of the 'balance' framework.
Read the following passage and answer the question.
A student is writing a research paper arguing that urban green spaces provide significant public health benefits. She has found the following sources:
Source 1: A Danish study tracking 900,000 people over ten years found that children who grew up with the least access to green space had a 55% higher risk of developing mental health disorders than those with the most access, after adjusting for socioeconomic factors.
Source 2: A University of Exeter study found that people who spent at least two hours per week in green spaces reported significantly better health and psychological well-being than those who did not, with the benefit plateauing at approximately five hours.
Source 3: The Trust for Public Land reports that 100 million Americans, including 28 million children, lack access to a park within a ten-minute walk of their home, with the gap concentrated in low-income communities and communities of color.
Source 4: A real estate analysis found that properties within 500 feet of a well-maintained park sell for 8-20% more than comparable properties without park access, suggesting that green spaces increase property values.
The student wants to add an environmental justice dimension to her public health argument. Which source combination best allows her to do this?
- ASources 3 and 4, because they demonstrate that green spaces have both social and economic value
- BSources 2 and 4, because they show that green spaces benefit both health and property values
- CSources 1 and 2, because they provide the strongest scientific evidence about health benefits of green spaces
- DSources 1 and 3, because Source 1 demonstrates the health consequences of lacking green space access while Source 3 shows that this lack disproportionately affects low-income communities and communities of colorCorrect
Why D is right
Environmental justice concerns the disproportionate impact of environmental conditions on marginalized communities. Source 1 provides evidence that lack of green space access causes measurable health harm (55% higher risk of mental health disorders). Source 3 shows that this lack of access disproportionately affects low-income communities and communities of color. Together, they demonstrate that a health-damaging environmental condition falls most heavily on already disadvantaged populations—the core of an environmental justice argument.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- Incorrect because while Source 3 addresses the distributional dimension, Source 4 addresses property values, which could actually complicate the environmental justice argument (green spaces raising property values can lead to gentrification and displacement of the communities they were meant to serve).
- B
- Incorrect because neither Source 2 nor Source 4 addresses the distributional question of who lacks access; environmental justice requires demonstrating that harm or deprivation falls disproportionately on marginalized groups.
- C
- Incorrect because while Sources 1 and 2 provide strong health evidence, Source 2 does not address the distributional dimension necessary for an environmental justice argument; it shows benefits for people who access green spaces without addressing who lacks access.