Read the following passage and answer the question.
The sanctuary city debate reveals a fundamental tension in American federalism: who controls immigration enforcement — the federal government, which has constitutional authority over immigration, or local governments, which have operational control over police departments, jails, and public services? Sanctuary cities do not, contrary to popular belief, prevent federal immigration agents from operating within their boundaries. They simply decline to use local resources — local police, local jail space, local tax dollars — to enforce federal immigration law. The legal principle is well established: the Tenth Amendment prohibits the federal government from 'commandeering' state and local officials to carry out federal programs. When a city declares itself a 'sanctuary,' it is asserting a constitutional prerogative, not defying the law.
The author most likely includes the reference to the Tenth Amendment in order to
- Asuggest that constitutional law is too complex and technical for ordinary citizens to fully understand its nuances
- Bargue that the Tenth Amendment should be repealed because it improperly limits federal authority over immigration enforcement
- Cacknowledge that sanctuary city policies raise legitimate public safety concerns that outweigh their legal justification
- Ddemonstrate that sanctuary city policies rest on a legitimate constitutional basis rather than on a lawless defiance of federal authorityCorrect
Why D is right
The Tenth Amendment reference provides constitutional grounding for sanctuary city policies, directly countering the common characterization of these cities as 'defying the law.' By showing that the policies rest on a legitimate constitutional basis rather than on lawless defiance of federal authority, the author reframes sanctuary cities as exercising legal rights rather than breaking them.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- Incorrect because the author explains the constitutional principle clearly and accessibly, not to suggest it is too complex or technical for readers to grasp.
- B
- Incorrect because the author invokes the Tenth Amendment to support sanctuary city policies as constitutionally grounded, not to argue that the amendment should be repealed.
- C
- Incorrect because the passage makes no acknowledgment of public safety concerns outweighing the legal justification; it focuses solely on the constitutional basis for sanctuary policies.