Skip to content
AP English Language and Composition · Claims and Evidence

Food deserts

Food deserts appears in 19 reviewed AP English Language and Composition questions and sits in Claims and Evidence. Below are worked examples showing exactly how the exam tests it, with the answer marked and every distractor explained.

How Food deserts is tested

Example 1Medium
Read the following passage and answer the question. The food desert is not a natural phenomenon. It is a product of redlining — the practice, begun in the 1930s by the Home Owners' Loan Corporation, of designating Black neighborhoods as 'hazardous' for mortgage lending. Banks refused to lend in redlined areas. Businesses followed the capital out. Grocery stores, pharmacies, and healthcare facilities relocated to suburbs where government-backed mortgages guaranteed a customer base. The neighborhoods left behind were not abandoned by their residents. They were abandoned by capital. Eighty years later, the maps of redlined neighborhoods and the maps of food deserts in American cities overlap with uncanny precision. This is not coincidence. It is inheritance. The author's assertion that food deserts are 'inheritance' rather than 'coincidence' implies which claim about their cause?
  1. AThe current geographic pattern of food deserts is a direct, traceable consequence of discriminatory housing policies enacted decades earlier.Correct
  2. BFood deserts occur with about the same frequency in every neighborhood, regardless of a community's racial or economic demographic makeup.
  3. CFood deserts result mainly from shifting contemporary consumer shopping habits and retail preferences, not from any decades-old policy decisions.
  4. DThe notion of food deserts is largely a myth, since reliable food access is roughly uniform across American geography.

Why A is right

By calling the overlap between redlined neighborhoods and food deserts 'inheritance' rather than 'coincidence,' the author claims a direct causal lineage: discriminatory policies of the 1930s produced the geographic patterns of food scarcity visible today. The word 'inheritance' implies that the consequences were transmitted across generations.
Why the other 3 choices miss
B
Incorrect because the passage argues that food deserts disproportionately affect formerly redlined (predominantly Black) neighborhoods, not that they are demographically uniform.
C
Incorrect because the passage traces food deserts to historical policy (redlining), not to contemporary consumer choices or retail preferences.
D
Incorrect because the passage provides detailed evidence for food deserts' existence and historical origins, not that they are a myth.
Example 2Easier
Read the following passage and answer the question. The food bank line forms at six in the morning. The food bank opens at nine. For three hours, families stand in a parking lot — in July heat, in January wind, in the predawn darkness of November — waiting for groceries they cannot afford to buy. They bring folding chairs and blankets. They bring children who should be in school. They bring the particular shame of people who have done everything they were told to do — worked hard, played by the rules, paid their taxes — and still cannot feed their families without charity. The line is long, and it grows longer each month. It is the visible edge of an invisible crisis: a food system that produces enough calories to feed every American twice over and distributes them so unevenly that forty-four million people experience food insecurity in the wealthiest nation on Earth. The descriptive detail of families bringing 'folding chairs and blankets' and 'children who should be in school' creates which effect?
  1. AIt creates a sentimental, overwrought tone that undermines the passage's claim to objective, analytical credibility.
  2. BIt argues that food banks should extend their operating hours so that working parents need not wait in a parking lot before dawn.
  3. CIt grounds the abstract concept of food insecurity in concrete, humanizing images that convey both the routine and the indignity of the experience.Correct
  4. DIt provides practical logistical information about food bank hours and procedures intended for prospective volunteers and donors.

Why C is right

The specific details — folding chairs for the three-hour stand in line, blankets for the cold, children missing school — transform 'food insecurity' from a statistical category into a lived experience. The details convey both the routine nature of the crisis (people come prepared, having done this before) and its indignity (children pulled out of school to stand in a parking lot for groceries).
Why the other 3 choices miss
A
Incorrect because the details strengthen rather than undermine the analysis by providing concrete evidence for abstract claims, not by weakening its credibility.
B
Incorrect because the passage is describing the human cost of food insecurity, not making a policy argument about food bank scheduling.
D
Incorrect because the details serve a rhetorical, evocative purpose, not an informational one aimed at volunteers or donors.
Example 3Medium
Read the following passage and answer the question. The food desert, the housing crisis, the healthcare desert, the broadband desert — these are not separate problems. They are the same problem expressed in different vocabularies. The communities that lack grocery stores also lack affordable housing. The communities that lack hospitals also lack high-speed internet. The communities that lack all of these also lack political representation proportional to their need, because the people who live in them are too busy working, too transient, too disenfranchised, or too exhausted to organize effectively. The American geography of deprivation is not random. It is patterned — along lines of race, class, and historical disinvestment — and it requires patterned solutions: not a food policy here and a housing policy there, but a comprehensive investment strategy that addresses the interconnected web of deprivation as a whole. The passage's primary organizational purpose is to
  1. Aprovide a detailed analysis of food deserts as the passage's single most urgent policy concern
  2. Bsynthesize separate crises into a unified diagnosis that demands comprehensive, not piecemeal, solutionsCorrect
  3. Cargue that political disenfranchisement is the root cause and therefore deserves priority over the other problems
  4. Dcompare the relative severity of food, housing, healthcare, and broadband deprivation to rank which is worst

Why B is right

The passage synthesizes food, housing, healthcare, and broadband deserts into a unified diagnosis: they are 'the same problem expressed in different vocabularies.' This synthesis demands comprehensive solutions that address the interconnected web rather than treating each issue in isolation, prioritizing one cause, or ranking severity.
Why the other 3 choices miss
A
Incorrect because the passage treats food deserts as just one of several equally interconnected crises, not as its single most urgent focus.
C
Incorrect because the passage frames disenfranchisement as one symptom among several, not as a root cause that justifies prioritizing it over the other problems.
D
Incorrect because the passage presents the deprivations as interconnected expressions of one problem rather than ranking their relative severity.

Studied alongside

Other concepts from Claims and Evidence.