Read the following passage, then answer the question.
We hold these truths to be self-evident — but they were not self-evident to the men who wrote them. Jefferson owned more than six hundred human beings over his lifetime. When he wrote 'all men are created equal,' he was writing as a slaveholder, in a document designed to secure the political rights of landowners. The phrase has outlasted its context because successive generations chose to take it more seriously than its author did. That is not an indictment of the ideals; it is an indictment of the gap. The Civil War, the women's suffrage movement, the civil rights movement, the disability rights movement — each has been, in part, a demand that America close that gap. The Declaration's power does not derive from what its signers believed but from what they wrote, which others have since used to hold the country accountable to its own language.
The author's primary rhetorical strategy in this passage is best described as...
- Ausing ethos by positioning the author as a uniquely credentialed historian with privileged, firsthand access to archival evidence
- Busing historical irony to reframe the Declaration's ideals as a resource for reform, not a founding achievementCorrect
- Cemploying logos to demonstrate methodically that the Declaration was, from its very inception, a deliberately fraudulent document
- Dappealing to pathos by cataloguing at length the suffering and injustice caused by the founders' persistent hypocrisy
Why B is right
The author acknowledges the contradiction between Jefferson's ideals and his actions, then reframes this not as a reason to dismiss the ideals but as the source of their ongoing power as a reform tool. The strategy is ironic but ultimately affirmative of the document's transformative potential, matching B.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- The author cites no credentials and presents no archival evidence; the argument is analytical and rhetorical, not credential-based.
- C
- The author explicitly resists calling the ideals fraudulent; the argument is more nuanced than a simple indictment.
- D
- While the passage acknowledges moral failings, it does not catalogue suffering or make a primarily emotional appeal.