Read the following passage, then answer the question.
What follows is not an argument for space exploration. It is something less convenient: a question. The question is this: if we possess the capability to establish a permanent human presence beyond Earth, and we choose not to, what does that choice say about us? I am not asking whether the expenditure is justified. I am not asking whether the technology is ready. I am asking whether a species that chooses to remain on a single planet when it has the means to expand to others has made a decision about its own future that it may not be able to unmake. This is not a question of engineering or economics. It is a question of identity. Are we a species that explores, or are we a species that explored — past tense — and then decided it had gone far enough? The difference between those two species is a single verb tense, and the distance between them is everything.
The author's framing of the passage as 'a question' rather than 'an argument' serves to
- Aavoid the burden of proving a specific claim with evidence while still implying a clear position through the question itselfCorrect
- Bsignal that the passage offers a genuinely balanced, two-sided overview of the ongoing debate over the merits of space exploration
- Cdemonstrate that space exploration is a topic on which no definitive argument can ever be made, given how evenly the evidence is split
- Dacknowledge that the author has not yet formed any opinion on whether space exploration is a worthwhile use of resources
Why A is right
By framing the passage as 'a question' rather than 'an argument,' the author avoids the burden of proving a specific claim with evidence, yet the question itself strongly implies a position: choosing not to explore is a diminishment of human identity. The rhetorical question is a vehicle for the argument without requiring the formal apparatus of argument.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- B
- Incorrect because the passage is not genuinely balanced; its questions imply a single position (pro-exploration) and frame the alternative (staying on Earth) as a diminishment of identity.
- C
- Incorrect because the passage does not suggest the topic is irresolvable or that the evidence is evenly split; it uses the question format to advance a specific perspective while avoiding the formal structure of argument.
- D
- Incorrect because the passage's questions are transparently rhetorical, carrying a clear implied position (that choosing not to explore diminishes the species); the author has plainly formed an opinion, even without stating it as a thesis.