Read the following passage, then answer the question.
In his 1906 novel 'The Jungle,' Upton Sinclair intended to write a book about the exploitation of immigrant labor in Chicago's meatpacking industry. The novel was a success — but not the success he intended. American readers were appalled by the book, but primarily by the revelations about contaminated meat, not by the plight of the workers. Congress passed the Pure Food and Drug Act of 1906 and the Meat Inspection Act largely in response to public outrage about the food safety sections of the novel. Sinclair later lamented: 'I aimed at the public's heart, and by accident I hit it in the stomach.' The sentence captures a persistent problem in persuasion: audiences receive arguments through the categories they already have, and the categories that matter most to an audience may not be the categories the speaker intends to activate.
Sinclair's remark that he 'aimed at the public's heart, and by accident I hit it in the stomach' is best understood as illustrating which principle of rhetoric?
- ARhetorical arguments should always prioritize self-interest over moral obligation to achieve maximum persuasive effect
- BIn general, pathos-based arguments are more effective than logos-based arguments at producing legislative and social change
- CAudiences interpret arguments through their own pre-existing concerns, which may diverge sharply from what the author intended to conveyCorrect
- DWriters should always research their audience before publishing so that an argument produces exactly the response they planned
Why C is right
Sinclair's observation illustrates that the audience's response was determined by what they were already primed to care about (food safety), not by what Sinclair wanted them to care about (labor exploitation). The argument was received through the audience's own categories, not through the author's intended frame.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- The passage does not advise prioritizing self-interest; it describes an unintended outcome and draws a principle about audience reception.
- B
- The passage does not compare pathos to logos; it analyzes why an intended emotional appeal (heart) produced a different response (stomach).
- D
- The passage draws a principle about audience psychology, not a practical recommendation about pre-publication research.
Read the following passage and answer the question.
The defenders of unpaid internships argue that interns receive compensation in the form of experience, mentorship, and professional connections. This framing performs a clever inversion: it transforms the extraction of labor into a gift to the laborer. But consider the logic more carefully. If an internship provides genuine skills and mentorship, it is a form of education—and the organization is acting as a school. Schools do not require their students to produce commercial value during their enrollment. If the intern is performing tasks that the organization would otherwise pay someone to do—answering phones, managing social media, conducting research, preparing reports—then the intern is a worker, and workers are entitled to wages. The experience argument cannot have it both ways: the intern cannot simultaneously be a student (who owes the organization gratitude) and a worker (who owes the organization productivity). One of these frames carries a legal obligation. The other does not. That is precisely why the "experience" frame is preferred.
The author's final two sentences ("One of these frames carries a legal obligation. The other does not. That is precisely why the 'experience' frame is preferred.") imply that
- Athe legal system adequately protects interns from exploitative working conditions
- Borganizations favor the 'experience' framing because it lets them avoid the legal duty to pay wagesCorrect
- Corganizations genuinely believe that internship experience is more valuable than monetary compensation
- Dinterns themselves prefer receiving experience over wages, believing it better serves their long-term career goals and networking prospects
Why B is right
The author distinguishes between two frames: the 'student' frame (no legal obligation to pay) and the 'worker' frame (legal obligation to pay wages). By stating that the 'experience' frame is preferred precisely because one frame carries legal obligations and the other does not, the author implies that organizations choose the 'experience/student' framing strategically to avoid the legal requirement to compensate workers.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- Incorrect because the passage implies the opposite: the ease with which organizations can classify interns as 'students' to avoid wage obligations suggests that the legal system fails to protect interns adequately.
- C
- Incorrect because the author frames the 'experience' argument as a 'clever inversion' and strategic choice, not a genuine belief; the passage attributes the framing to self-interest, not sincerity.
- D
- Incorrect because the passage does not address intern preferences; it focuses on organizational motivations for choosing a particular framing, and the author treats that framing as an imposition on interns, not a reflection of their desires.
Read the following passage, then answer the question.
Passage 1 (from a labor history, 2003):
The garment workers who organized in New York City in the 1900s faced a labor market structured entirely against them: surplus immigrant labor, employers who moved work to non-union states at the first sign of organizing, and a legal system that typically sided with property over labor. Their achievement was to build solidarity across language barriers — Italian, Yiddish, Polish, English — in an industry specifically designed to keep workers isolated. The ILGWU's early organizing drives succeeded not through formal legal mechanisms but through the force of collective identity forged in the shops and tenements of the Lower East Side.
Passage 2 (from a sociologist's analysis of the same period, 2006):
The romantic narrative of immigrant solidarity in early garment worker organizing obscures the real divisions that union organizers had to manage: between skilled and unskilled workers, between more established immigrants and newer arrivals, between workers who feared deportation and those who did not. The ILGWU's organizing success was partial and fragile, and its model depended on specific conditions — dense residential proximity, common workplaces, overlapping community institutions — that are not present in most contemporary labor organizing contexts.
A researcher studying contemporary labor organizing would find which combination of claims from both passages most useful for understanding why organizing is harder today?
- APassage 1's celebration of collective identity forged among garment workers, and Passage 2's argument that identity-based solidarity is inherently unstable over time
- BPassage 1's focus on the legal system's hostility to labor, and Passage 2's argument that formal legal mechanisms and government intervention were the primary tools driving ILGWU organizing
- CPassage 1's claim that solidarity was forged despite barriers, and Passage 2's identification of the specific conditions that made that solidarity possibleCorrect
- DBoth passages' agreement that immigrant workers across skilled and unskilled trades were uniformly committed to labor organizing regardless of individual circumstances
Why C is right
The researcher benefits from Passage 1's account of how solidarity was built (shared identity across language barriers in dense workplaces) and Passage 2's specification of the conditions that made this possible (residential proximity, common workplaces, overlapping institutions). Together they explain both the achievement and the structural conditions it required — and therefore why those conditions' absence today makes organizing harder.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- Passage 2 does not argue that identity-based solidarity is inherently unstable; it argues the model was condition-dependent.
- B
- Passage 1 argues that formal legal mechanisms were not the basis of success; Passage 2 does not argue that legal mechanisms or government intervention drove ILGWU's successes.
- D
- Passage 2 explicitly notes divisions among workers across skilled/unskilled lines and individual circumstances, contradicting any claim of uniform commitment.