Read the following passage, then answer the question.
The restaurant guide described the dish as 'a meditation on impermanence.' I had ordered oxtail. The oxtail was good — braised, rich, falling from the bone — in the way that oxtail is when someone has taken the time to do it correctly. I do not know in what sense it meditated or on what. The phrase 'meditation on impermanence' belongs to a vocabulary of food criticism that has detached itself from the experience of eating and floated somewhere overhead, looking down at people chewing and finding them conceptually significant. Eating is not a meditation. It is eating. The food that is best remembered is not the food that meant the most but the food that tasted the most, and the two are rarely the same thing.
The author's tone toward the language of food criticism in this passage is best described as...
- Aacademically detached, analyzing food criticism as a cultural phenomenon without personal investment
- Bgently satirical, deflating food criticism's pretensions by insisting on the primacy of direct sensory experienceCorrect
- Cbitterly dismissive, treating the entire discourse of food criticism as an elaborate, contemptible fraud perpetrated on unsuspecting diners
- Dadmiring, appreciating the effort critics make to elevate the cultural status of gastronomy
Why B is right
The author's tone is wry and lightly satirical — describing food criticism's vocabulary as 'floating overhead' and reducing its pretension with a deadpan ('I had ordered oxtail') — but the critique is gentle rather than bitter, ending with an affirmative claim about tasting. B captures this well-aimed, good-humored deflation.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- The author is personally and humorously invested; the tone is not detached.
- C
- The critique is light and even affectionate in its way; 'bitterly dismissive' overstates the hostility of a passage that ends with a warm claim about tasting.
- D
- The author clearly critiques food criticism's pretension; there is no admiration for the elevated vocabulary.