Read the following passage and answer the question.
The rewilding debate reveals a deeper disagreement about the purpose of nature. For the conservation biologist, nature is a system to be understood and managed—a set of interacting populations, nutrient cycles, and energy flows that can be optimized for biodiversity. For the rewilding advocate, nature is a process to be trusted—an unfolding drama whose most creative acts occur when human management withdraws. For the farmer whose sheep are killed by a reintroduced wolf, nature is a force to be negotiated—a daily reality of predation, weather, and economic pressure that philosophers rarely experience firsthand. Each perspective contains a partial truth. The danger lies in allowing any single perspective to dominate the conversation, because the conversation itself—the negotiation between system, process, and experience—is where workable policy emerges.
The author organizes the passage by presenting three perspectives on nature in order to
- Aargue that productive policy requires integrating all three rather than privileging any single viewpointCorrect
- Bsatirize the impracticality of all three perspectives to propose a fourth alternative
- Crank them from least to most valid and argue that the farmer's perspective should prevail
- Ddemonstrate that each perspective is entirely self-sufficient and needs no supplementation from the others
Why A is right
The author presents three perspectives, identifies each as a 'partial truth,' and concludes that 'the negotiation between system, process, and experience' is where good policy emerges. This argues for integration, not ranking (A), self-sufficiency (B), or satirical dismissal (D).
Why the other 3 choices miss
- B
- Incorrect because the author treats all three perspectives respectfully and does not introduce a fourth alternative.
- C
- Incorrect because the author explicitly cautions against allowing 'any single perspective to dominate,' including the farmer's.
- D
- Incorrect because describing each as a 'partial truth' implies incompleteness, not self-sufficiency.
Read the following passage and answer the question.
A student is preparing a presentation on the impact of remote work on urban economies. She has compiled the following data:
Source 1: A workplace research firm's 2024 report found that office occupancy in major U.S. cities remains at 50% of pre-pandemic levels, with commercial real estate vacancies reaching historic highs of 19.6% nationally.
Source 2: An urban economics research study found that neighborhoods with high concentrations of office workers experienced a 32% decline in weekday foot traffic, leading to closures of 41% of lunch-focused restaurants and 28% of dry cleaners in those areas.
Source 3: A national labor statistics survey reported that remote-capable jobs grew from 24% of all positions in 2019 to 37% in 2024, with the shift concentrated in finance, technology, and professional services.
Source 4: An economist's research found that hybrid workers (3 days in-office, 2 remote) reported 8% higher job satisfaction and showed equivalent productivity to full-time in-office workers, with companies saving an average of $11,000 per employee annually in reduced real estate costs.
The student wants to demonstrate that remote work has created a cascade of economic effects beyond just the employer-employee relationship. Which organizational approach would best accomplish this?
- APresent Source 2 first because restaurant closures are the most emotionally compelling detail and will capture audience attention
- BPresent Source 4 first to establish that remote work benefits employers, then ignore Sources 1 and 2 as irrelevant to the economic argument
- CPresent Sources 3, 1, and 2 in sequence to show how the growth of remote work led to office vacancies, which then caused downstream losses in surrounding businessesCorrect
- DPresent all four sources simultaneously in a single paragraph to avoid repetition and maintain conciseness
Why C is right
The cascade argument requires showing a chain of cause and effect: the growth of remote work (Source 3) led to reduced office occupancy and commercial vacancies (Source 1), which then caused downstream economic damage to surrounding businesses (Source 2). Presenting these sources in causal sequence demonstrates the cascade effect the student wants to illustrate—each link in the chain leading to the next.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- Incorrect because leading with Source 2 (downstream effects) before establishing Source 3 (the cause) would present consequences before causes, undermining the causal logic of the cascade argument.
- B
- Incorrect because ignoring Sources 1 and 2 would eliminate the very evidence of cascade effects (office vacancies, business closures) that the student wants to demonstrate; the argument requires showing impacts beyond the employer-employee relationship.
- D
- Incorrect because presenting all sources simultaneously obscures the causal chain the student is trying to illustrate; the cascade effect requires sequential presentation to show how each change triggers the next.
Read the following passage and answer the question.
A student is writing a research paper about food deserts—areas where residents lack access to affordable, nutritious food. She has collected the following information:
Source 1: USDA data identifying 6,500 food desert census tracts in the United States, with 19 million Americans living more than one mile from a supermarket in urban areas or more than ten miles in rural areas.
Source 2: A Johns Hopkins study found that when a new supermarket opened in a food desert neighborhood in Baltimore, residents' fruit and vegetable consumption increased by only 2.1%, and the majority continued shopping at the same convenience stores they had used before.
Source 3: A community health worker's testimony: "The problem isn't just that there's no grocery store. It's that people work two jobs, have no car, don't know how to cook fresh food because they never learned, and are exhausted. Putting a store on the corner doesn't fix any of that."
Source 4: A nutrition education program in Detroit that combined cooking classes, subsidized produce delivery, and community meal preparation reported that participant households increased their vegetable consumption by 47% over six months.
The student wants to argue that solving food deserts requires more than simply increasing food access. Which organizational strategy would most effectively support this argument?
- APresent Source 3 first because personal testimony is always more persuasive than data, then summarize the remaining sources briefly
- BPresent Source 1 to establish the scope of food deserts, Source 2 to show that access alone is insufficient, Source 3 to explain why through firsthand testimony, and Source 4 to illustrate what a more comprehensive solution looks likeCorrect
- CPresent Sources 1 through 4 in reverse order to build suspense toward the revelation that food deserts affect 19 million Americans
- DPresent Source 1 to define the problem, then Source 4 to propose a solution, ignoring Sources 2 and 3
Why B is right
This organizational strategy builds the argument sequentially: Source 1 establishes that food deserts are a real, large-scale problem; Source 2 provides empirical evidence that increasing access alone does not significantly change behavior; Source 3 explains the underlying reasons through the authority of lived experience; and Source 4 demonstrates that a multifaceted approach produces dramatically better results. Each source builds on the previous one to support the thesis that access alone is insufficient.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- Incorrect because beginning with testimony before establishing the factual context would leave readers without the framework needed to understand the testimony's significance; also, personal testimony is not inherently more persuasive than data—different types of evidence serve different functions.
- C
- Incorrect because reverse order would present the solution before the problem and the explanation before the evidence, creating logical confusion rather than a coherent argument; suspense is not an appropriate organizational principle for an evidence-based research paper.
- D
- Incorrect because ignoring Sources 2 and 3 would eliminate the evidence showing that access alone is insufficient, which is the central claim the student wants to support; without those sources, the argument collapses.