Read the following passage.
Note 1: The average American generates 4.4 pounds of municipal solid waste per day, compared to 2.4 pounds per day for the average European, according to EPA and Eurostat data.
Note 2: Only 32% of municipal solid waste in the United States is recycled or composted, while the European Union achieves a 48% recycling rate, partly due to extended producer responsibility laws that require manufacturers to fund end-of-life disposal of their products.
Note 3: A 2024 MIT study found that consumer behavior change alone (without policy intervention) accounts for less than 5% of measurable reductions in waste generation.
A writer wants to argue that reducing waste in the United States requires policy solutions rather than individual behavior change alone. Which choice most effectively uses the notes to support this argument?
- AThe MIT study found that individual behavior change accounts for under 5% of measurable waste reduction, a finding that indicates new government policies would likely prove just as ineffective as relying on consumers alone.
- BThe EU's higher recycling rate stems partly from extended producer responsibility laws, and the MIT study confirms behavior change alone yields minimal waste reduction.Correct
- CAmericans generate nearly twice as much waste per day as Europeans, a gap the writer can use to argue that better educating consumers about their own consumption habits is the most effective solution.
- DBecause only 32% of U.S. waste is currently recycled or composted, the country should focus its efforts on expanding recycling infrastructure and running consumer awareness campaigns.
Why B is right
This choice combines the EU policy example (Note 2) with the MIT finding that consumer behavior change alone is insufficient (Note 3), directly supporting the argument that policy solutions are necessary.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- Incorrect because it misinterprets the MIT study; the study shows that behavior change alone is insufficient, not that policy intervention is also ineffective.
- C
- Incorrect because it attributes the solution to consumer education, which contradicts the argument that policy (not just individual behavior) is needed.
- D
- Incorrect because 'consumer awareness campaigns' are behavior-change strategies, not the policy solutions the argument calls for.