Read the following passage and answer the question.
Prison abolition rhetoric deliberately unsettles. Where reform discourse speaks of "improving conditions," "reducing recidivism," and "evidence-based practices," abolition discourse speaks of "freedom," "transformation," and "a world without cages." The vocabulary is not accidental; it is strategic. Reform language operates within the grammar of the existing system, accepting its premises while adjusting its parameters. Abolition language refuses that grammar entirely, substituting a vocabulary that makes the current system seem not merely imperfect but incomprehensible—as foreign as feudalism, as indefensible as slavery. This rhetorical strategy carries risks: audiences accustomed to reform's measured tones may dismiss abolition's radical lexicon as utopian or naive. But the abolitionists' wager is that incremental language produces incremental thought, and incremental thought will never generate the imaginative leap required to envision a fundamentally different approach to harm and accountability.
The author presents the abolitionists' rhetorical strategy as one that
- Aimitates the reform movement's vocabulary in order to make abolition seem like a natural extension of existing policy
- Brelies primarily on statistical evidence about incarceration rates to persuade skeptical audiences
- Csacrifices political credibility in pursuit of maintaining the status quo within the criminal justice system
- Ddeliberately risks alienating moderate audiences in order to expand the boundaries of what is politically imaginableCorrect
Why D is right
The passage describes abolitionists' choice to use radical language despite the risk of seeming utopian, based on the calculation that only radical language can produce the 'imaginative leap' needed. This is a deliberate trade-off between accessibility and transformative scope. They do not maintain the status quo (A), rely on statistics (C), or imitate reform language (D).
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- Incorrect because the passage explicitly states that abolition language 'refuses that grammar entirely,' contrasting with reform language rather than imitating it.
- B
- Incorrect because the passage describes a rhetorical strategy focused on vocabulary and imagination, not statistical persuasion.
- C
- Incorrect because the abolitionists aim to dismantle, not maintain, the current system; the risk is to their credibility, not to the status quo.