Read the following passage and answer the question.
The case for public art funding rests on a premise that many taxpayers find difficult to accept: that beauty is not a luxury but a necessity. Study after study has demonstrated that communities with robust public art programs experience measurable benefits—reduced vandalism, increased foot traffic in commercial districts, stronger neighborhood identity, and improved mental health outcomes among residents. The National Endowment for the Arts reports that every dollar of federal arts funding generates nine dollars in local economic activity. Yet critics dismiss these figures as creative accounting, arguing that private philanthropy and market forces should determine which art survives. This objection misunderstands the fundamental purpose of public art. Unlike gallery art, which serves those who choose to seek it out, public art serves everyone—the construction worker passing a mural on her commute, the child encountering a sculpture in a park, the elderly man who finds a bench beside a mosaic where he can rest and feel, for a moment, that his city cares about beauty.
The author's argument would be most strengthened by including which of the following?
- ATestimony from residents describing how specific public art installations changed their daily commutes
- BStatistical evidence that communities which stopped funding public art saw measurable declines in those same benefitsCorrect
- CA list of well-known artists whose early careers were launched through public arts grants and commissions
- DA comparison of private philanthropic giving to the arts across several past decades and regions
Why B is right
The author's argument claims public art produces measurable benefits (reduced vandalism, increased foot traffic, improved mental health). Showing that removing public art funding leads to declines in those same benefits would establish a stronger causal link, demonstrating that the benefits are attributable to public art rather than coincidental.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- Incorrect because the passage already includes anecdotal examples (the construction worker, child, elderly man). Additional testimony would reinforce the emotional appeal but would not address the logical gap in establishing causation.
- C
- Incorrect because the argument is about the community-wide benefits of public art, not about the careers of individual artists. Famous artists' origins are tangential to the central claim.
- D
- Incorrect because comparing private philanthropy levels across decades is relevant to the critic's position, not to strengthening the author's case that public art produces community benefits.