Skip to content
AP English Language and Composition · Style and Tone

Redefinition

Redefinition appears in 9 reviewed AP English Language and Composition questions and sits in Style and Tone. Below are worked examples showing exactly how the exam tests it, with the answer marked and every distractor explained.

How Redefinition is tested

Example 1Harder
Read the following passage. "We do not ask that you feel our pain — empathy, in our experience, is a gift the comfortable offer when they wish to avoid the more costly gift of action. We do not ask that you understand our culture — understanding, too, can be a form of consumption, an intellectual tourism that leaves the tourist enriched and the destination unchanged. We ask only this: that you listen without interpreting, that you witness without narrating, and that when we have finished speaking, you do not explain us to ourselves. We have been explained enough. We have been theorized, categorized, anthropologized, and displayed. What we require now is not comprehension but space — the simple, radical space to exist without being someone else's subject of study." The passage's rejection of empathy and understanding as insufficient responses is best characterized as
  1. Aa self-contradictory move that undermines the author's credibility by rejecting the good-faith engagement the argument otherwise depends on
  2. Ba rhetorical exaggeration meant to provoke controversy and outrage rather than to build persuasive common ground
  3. Can illogical position that undermines the argument by alienating the very allies it seeks to persuade
  4. Da strategic redefinition that exposes how seemingly positive responses can function as forms of appropriationCorrect

Why D is right

The passage redefines empathy as 'a gift the comfortable offer when they wish to avoid action' and understanding as 'intellectual tourism.' These strategic redefinitions reveal how responses that seem positive can actually serve the interests of the responder rather than the speaker, functioning as forms of appropriation rather than genuine solidarity.
Why the other 3 choices miss
A
Incorrect because rejecting insufficient responses while articulating better alternatives is logically consistent, not self-contradictory.
B
Incorrect because the passage carefully distinguishes between what it rejects (empathy, understanding) and what it requests (listening, witnessing, space), demonstrating persuasive specificity rather than exaggeration for outrage.
C
Incorrect because the passage does not reject allies but redefines the terms of alliance, asking for space and listening rather than empathy and understanding.

Studied alongside

Other concepts from Style and Tone.