Read the following passage, then answer the question.
The economist Albert Hirschman, in 'The Rhetoric of Reaction' (1991), identified three standard arguments used by opponents of progressive reforms across two centuries. The 'perversity thesis' holds that the reform will produce the opposite of what it intends; the 'futility thesis' holds that nothing fundamental will change regardless of the reform; and the 'jeopardy thesis' holds that the reform will endanger prior achievements. What made Hirschman's analysis unusual was that he applied it symmetrically: he concluded that progressive defenders of reform had their own standard counterarguments (the 'history is on our side' argument, the 'intransigence will be more costly' argument), which were equally formulaic. His point was not that conservatives were wrong and progressives right, but that both sides' standard arguments were rhetorical performances rather than genuine engagements with the specific merits of specific proposals.
Hirschman's decision to apply his rhetorical analysis symmetrically to both conservatives and progressives primarily serves which purpose?
- AIt shows that formulaic rhetoric displacing substantive engagement with specific proposals is a structural feature of political argument generally, not a partisan pathologyCorrect
- BIt allows him to appeal to conservative readers who might otherwise dismiss his analysis of reform opponents' rhetoric as merely a partisan brief for progressive causes
- CIt establishes his political neutrality as a rhetorical credential, making his criticism of both sides' argumentative habits seem more credible to a general audience
- DIt implies that progressive and conservative positions are equally valid and that the underlying policy disputes cannot ultimately be resolved through argument
Why A is right
By applying the analysis to both sides, Hirschman shows that the problem is structural — the formula-driven nature of political rhetoric — not something inherent to one political tradition. The symmetry diagnoses a condition of political argument generally, not a specific faction's failure.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- B
- The passage does not discuss Hirschman's marketing strategy; the symmetry serves the analytical point.
- C
- The passage attributes the symmetry to an intellectual point about the structural nature of the problem, not to a strategic credential-building move.
- D
- Hirschman does not imply that the underlying policy questions cannot be resolved; he argues that the standard rhetorical arguments are inadequate for resolving them.