Read the following passage and answer the question.
The debate over vaccine mandates exposes a tension that democratic societies have never fully resolved: the conflict between individual autonomy and collective welfare. A person's right to make medical decisions for herself is among the most deeply held principles in liberal democracies. Yet vaccination operates through collective, not individual, protection. The unvaccinated person endangers not only herself but also those who cannot be vaccinated—infants, immunocompromised patients, the elderly whose immune systems no longer respond robustly to vaccines. Herd immunity is a communal achievement that depends on sufficient individual participation; it collapses when too many individuals opt out. Neither side of this debate is wrong in principle. Individual autonomy matters. Collective welfare matters. The difficulty is that in the specific case of vaccination, one cannot be fully honored without partially compromising the other.
The primary purpose of the passage is to
- Aargue that vaccine mandates should be universally implemented to protect public health
- Bpresent the vaccine mandate debate as an inherent tension between two legitimate valuesCorrect
- Cpropose a compromise solution that satisfies both proponents and opponents of vaccine mandates
- Dcriticize individuals who refuse vaccination for prioritizing personal choice over community safety
Why B is right
The passage explicitly frames the debate as a genuine tension between two valid principles: individual autonomy and collective welfare. The author states 'Neither side of this debate is wrong in principle' and concludes that fully honoring one requires 'partially compromising the other,' presenting the issue as an inherent tension rather than advocating for either side.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- Incorrect because the author does not advocate for mandates; the passage presents both sides as legitimate and acknowledges the difficulty of reconciling them.
- C
- Incorrect because the passage diagnoses the tension without proposing any specific solution or compromise; it ends by identifying the difficulty rather than resolving it.
- D
- Incorrect because the passage treats individual autonomy as a 'deeply held principle' worthy of respect, not as something to be criticized when exercised.