Skip to content
AP English Literature and Composition · Poetry

Contemplation

Contemplation appears in 3 reviewed AP English Literature and Composition questions and sits in Poetry. Below are worked examples showing exactly how the exam tests it, with the answer marked and every distractor explained.

How Contemplation is tested

Example 1Medium
Read the following passage. The walls of Cell 47 held the collected wisdom of its previous occupants, scratched into plaster with fingernails and smuggled pencils. 'Time is a circle—Inmate 302.' 'God is a guard who never checks his radio—Anonymous.' 'Freedom is remembering you had legs—K.W.' The graffiti was a library written by people who had no access to libraries, a conversation conducted across years by people who had never met, each message adding a verse to a psalm of confinement that grew longer with every sentence served. Julian read the walls the way seminarians read scripture—looking for the verse that would explain his particular suffering. He found it on the wall behind the toilet, written in handwriting so small it was almost a whisper: 'The worst prison is the one you agree to.' He thought about this for seven months. He thought about it while eating meals that had been designed by committee, wearing clothes that had been chosen by statute, breathing air that had been rationed by architecture. He thought about it until the sentence stopped being about prison and started being about everything—about the marriages you stay in, the jobs you hate, the versions of yourself you maintain because demolition is more frightening than disrepair. The graffiti message 'The worst prison is the one you agree to' undergoes what transformation through Julian's extended contemplation?
  1. AIt convinces Julian that his imprisonment is a just punishment he has rightfully earned through his crimes
  2. BIt loses all coherence and meaning as Julian's prolonged isolation gradually erodes his grip on sanity
  3. CIt shifts from a literal remark about incarceration into a broad metaphor for self-imposed confinementCorrect
  4. DIt hardens into a resolve to plan a literal, physical escape and break free from his prison cell

Why C is right

Over seven months, Julian's contemplation transforms the graffiti from a specific commentary on incarceration ('the worst prison') into a universal observation about all forms of voluntary confinement—marriages endured, hated jobs, maintained false selves. The message 'stopped being about prison and started being about everything,' demonstrating how sustained reflection can expand a literal statement into a metaphor with existential reach.
Why the other 3 choices miss
A
Incorrect because the message concerns voluntary confinement ('the one you agree to'), which is an observation about agency and choice, not a justification of Julian's punishment as deserved.
B
Incorrect because Julian's contemplation is described as productive and expanding, not as a sign of deterioration; the message gains meaning over time rather than dissolving into incoherence.
D
Incorrect because Julian's response is philosophical rather than practical; he applies the message to internal confinement (marriages, jobs, identities), not to a physical escape from the cell.

Studied alongside

Other concepts from Poetry.