Skip to content
AP English Literature and Composition · Poetry

Gardening

Gardening appears in 3 reviewed AP English Literature and Composition questions and sits in Poetry. Below are worked examples showing exactly how the exam tests it, with the answer marked and every distractor explained.

How Gardening is tested

Example 1Easier
Read the following passage carefully before choosing your answer. Mrs. Petrosyan's garden was a grammar. The roses were her nouns—stable, identifiable, planted in rows that proceeded with the orderliness of a well-constructed sentence. The herbs were her verbs—active, necessary, constantly being cut and used and growing back. The wildflowers along the fence were her adjectives—beautiful but, she admitted, expendable; the garden could survive without them, though it would be diminished. But the weeds—the weeds were her favorite part of speech. 'They are the questions,' she said. 'Every garden has questions it did not plant, and the gardener who pulls every weed is a gardener who has decided that the garden should contain only answers, which is a garden that has stopped growing.' Mrs. Petrosyan's decision to keep weeds as 'questions' most directly characterizes her as
  1. Aan academic linguist who reflexively applies formal grammatical theory to ordinary life
  2. Bsomeone who welcomes the unplanned and the challenging as essential to real growthCorrect
  3. Ca naturalist who dislikes cultivated flowers and prefers a wild landscape
  4. Da negligent gardener who fails to keep her property to accepted community standards

Why B is right

Mrs. Petrosyan keeps weeds because they represent 'questions the garden did not plant,' and a garden containing only answers 'has stopped growing.' Her tolerance for weeds characterizes her as someone who values openness to the unplanned, the uninvited, and the challenging—understanding that growth requires room for what was not anticipated, and that eliminating every disruption produces stagnation.
Why the other 3 choices miss
A
Incorrect because the grammar metaphor is a creative framework for expressing her gardening philosophy, not evidence of formal academic linguistic training.
C
Incorrect because Mrs. Petrosyan deliberately cultivates roses, herbs, and wildflowers alongside the weeds; she values flowers rather than rejecting them for a wild landscape.
D
Incorrect because her garden is highly organized (roses in rows, herbs active, wildflowers along the fence); keeping weeds is a considered philosophical choice, not negligence.
Example 2Easier
Read the following dramatic excerpt carefully before choosing your answer. Setting: A rooftop garden. MIRA, 30s, tends plants while her friend, ALEX, 30s, watches. ALEX: I don't understand why you garden on a rooftop. The wind kills half of what you plant. MIRA: Forty percent. I've calculated. ALEX: So you know in advance that almost half of everything you grow will die. MIRA: Everything I grow will die eventually. The wind just speeds it up for some of them. ALEX: That doesn't bother you? MIRA: It used to. Then I realized I wasn't gardening for the harvest. I was gardening for the gardening. The sixty percent that survives is a bonus. The forty percent that doesn't -- that's the tuition. ALEX: Tuition for what? MIRA: For learning how to put something in the ground knowing the odds, and doing it anyway. (pause) I think that's called hope. Or stupidity. The line is thinner than people think. Mira's comparison of plant loss to "tuition" most directly reframes failure as
  1. Athe price of learning to persist despite uncertain outcomes, a lesson she likens to hopeCorrect
  2. Ba literal financial expense that makes rooftop gardening prohibitively costly to sustain
  3. Can unacceptable waste of resources that careful advance planning could have prevented entirely
  4. Dproof that rooftop gardening is fundamentally impractical and ought to be given up on

Why A is right

Mira calls the forty percent loss 'tuition' -- a fee paid for learning. What she learns is 'how to put something in the ground knowing the odds, and doing it anyway,' which she identifies as either 'hope or stupidity.' The tuition metaphor reframes failure not as waste but as the cost of an education in persistence. The lost plants are the price of learning to act despite known risk, which is her working definition of hope.
Why the other 3 choices miss
B
Incorrect because 'tuition' is metaphorical, referring to the experiential cost of learning persistence, not to literal financial expense.
C
Incorrect because Mira explicitly accepts the loss as a feature of her practice, not a problem to solve; she has 'calculated' the rate and incorporated it into her philosophy.
D
Incorrect because Mira's response to the loss is not to abandon gardening but to reframe the loss as meaningful; the forty percent is 'tuition,' not a reason to quit.

Studied alongside

Other concepts from Poetry.