Read the following poem.
Pastoral with Surveillance Cameras
The sheep have been fitted with GPS collars.
The shepherd checks his phone.
In the meadow, which is leased
from a corporation based in Luxembourg,
the wildflowers are a trademarked cultivar
engineered to bloom on schedule.
The brook—I am contractually obligated
to call it a brook—is a drainage channel
lined with eco-friendly polymer,
and the birdsong you hear
is a recording, motion-activated,
designed to improve property values
by 3.7 percent.
I wanted to write a pastoral.
I wanted the old green lie—
that nature is simple, that labor is noble,
that the creek gives freely of its music.
But the creek is a drainage channel
and the music is a .wav file
and the shepherd is checking his portfolio.
What remains pastoral:
the light, which no one has monetized yet,
falling equally on the trademarked flowers
and the un-trademarked dirt between them.
The poem's relationship to the pastoral tradition is best described as
- Aa total rejection insisting the pastoral mode is no longer possible under corporate ownership of the land
- Ban anti-pastoral that critiques the tradition's idealization while preserving a residual pastoral impulseCorrect
- Ca sincere continuation that simply updates the tradition's imagery for a contemporary, technology-saturated audience
- Da satirical parody whose chief aim is to ridicule readers who still find comfort in conventional nature poetry
Why B is right
The poem systematically dismantles pastoral conventions (the shepherd, the brook, the birdsong) by revealing their corporate mediation. However, the final stanza rescues one element—light—that remains unmonetized, preserving a genuine pastoral moment within the anti-pastoral framework. This dual movement (critique plus residual longing) defines the poem's complex relationship to the tradition.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- Incorrect because the final stanza's celebration of unmonetized light shows the poem has not declared the pastoral impossible; it locates one surviving element worthy of pastoral attention.
- C
- Incorrect because the poem does not simply update pastoral imagery but actively critiques the conditions that make traditional pastoral impossible; the corporate mediation is presented as a problem, not an adaptation.
- D
- Incorrect because the poem's critique targets economic systems and the commodification of nature, not readers of nature poetry; the tone is elegiac rather than contemptuous.