Skip to content
AP English Literature and Composition · Prose Fiction

Symbolism

Symbolism appears in 140 reviewed AP English Literature and Composition questions and sits in Prose Fiction. Below are worked examples showing exactly how the exam tests it, with the answer marked and every distractor explained.

How Symbolism is tested

Example 1Medium
Read the following poem carefully before choosing your answer. The map still shows the river where my mother washed our clothes, but the river has moved east by twenty meters since the map was drawn. This is the argument between the record and the real: the map insists the river is here; the river insists it is not. I have learned to trust the river. Maps are promises made by people who believed the world would hold still long enough to be described. The poem's treatment of the conflict between the map and the river most fully develops which thematic idea?
  1. ACartography is an unreliable science that should be replaced by direct observation
  2. BFixed representations inevitably fail to capture lived reality's continuous changeCorrect
  3. CRivers are inherently more trustworthy than the human-made documents that describe them
  4. DThe speaker's mother was mistaken to depend on the shifting river for the household's washing

Why B is right

The poem sets the fixed representation (map) against the changing reality (river that 'has moved east by twenty meters'). Maps are described as 'promises / made by people who believed / the world would hold still / long enough to be described.' The thematic idea is that any fixed representation -- map, record, description -- is a promise of stability that reality, in its continuous change, will eventually break.
Why the other 3 choices miss
A
Incorrect because the poem uses maps as a metaphor for all fixed representations rather than literally critiquing cartography as a science; the argument is philosophical, not practical.
C
Incorrect because the poem is not ranking the moral trustworthiness of rivers against documents; it uses the river/map conflict to explore the broader relationship between representation and reality, not to declare one kind of thing more reliable.
D
Incorrect because the mother's use of the river is presented as a grounding memory, not as an error; the poem never faults her reliance on the river but uses it as part of its metaphorical structure.
Example 2Harder
Read the following poem carefully before choosing your answer. The well has two stories to tell: one of darkness, one of depth. Ask the bucket and it will say the well is generous, wet, essential. Ask the stone dropped in for wishing and it will say the well is hungry, a mouth that swallows prayers and returns only echo. Both are telling the truth. The well does not choose what is lowered into it. It only knows the weight of what it holds and the lightness of what it has released. The well in this poem most fully represents
  1. Athe natural environment's vulnerability to human exploitation and pollution of shared resources
  2. Bthe dual nature of any experience, which sustains or consumes depending on what one brings to itCorrect
  3. Cthe fundamental opposition between practical and spiritual ways of approaching the natural world
  4. Dthe speaker's rural childhood home and the deep nostalgia associated with a vanished way of life

Why B is right

The well tells 'two stories' -- one of generosity (to the bucket that draws water) and one of hunger (to the wishing stone that is swallowed). The poem's resolution is that both are true and the well 'does not choose / what is lowered into it.' The well represents the dual nature of experience: the same depth can sustain or consume depending on what is brought to it, and this duality is inherent rather than chosen.
Why the other 3 choices miss
A
Incorrect because the poem does not address exploitation or pollution; the well serves as a philosophical symbol for duality, not an environmental commentary about shared resources.
C
Incorrect because the poem's point is that both the practical (bucket) and spiritual (wishing stone) perspectives are equally valid; it presents them as coexisting truths rather than as fundamentally opposed approaches.
D
Incorrect because the poem contains no biographical or nostalgic content; the well is presented as a universal symbol rather than a personal memory of a rural home.
Example 3Medium
Read the following poem. The blackbird on the wire does not know it is a symbol. It sits because the wire is there and sitting is what blackbirds do when wires are available, which is a motivation no poet has ever found sufficient. We need the bird to mean. We need its darkness against the snow-white sky to stand for grief, or solitude, or the note of minor key in an otherwise major landscape. The bird does not cooperate. It flies when it is ready. It sings when it is hungry. It leaves the wire without regard for the stanza it was sitting in or the reader who was just beginning to feel something, which is the bird's greatest gift — the refusal to be anything other than a bird, which is more than most of us can say about ourselves. The poem's central concern is most accurately described as
  1. Aan argument that poetry should abandon figurative language in favor of plain, literal description of the natural world
  2. Ba celebration of the blackbird as the most symbolically rich and frequently invoked creature in Western poetry
  3. Ca meditation on the human impulse to assign symbolic meaning and nature's indifference to being interpretedCorrect
  4. Da critique of amateur birdwatching for prizing aesthetic response over accurate ornithological observation

Why C is right

The poem explores the tension between the human compulsion to make the bird 'mean' something (grief, solitude, a minor key) and the bird's indifference to symbolic assignment. 'The bird does not cooperate' because it exists as 'a bird,' not as a symbol, and its 'greatest gift' is 'the refusal to be anything other than' itself. This tension between human meaning-making and natural indifference constitutes the poem's central concern, examined with wry self-awareness about the poet's own complicity in the process.
Why the other 3 choices miss
A
Incorrect because the poem itself uses figurative language throughout (the bird 'does not cooperate,' the wire is a 'stanza'); it examines the tension rather than resolving it in favor of literalism.
B
Incorrect because the poem's project is to strip the blackbird of symbolic richness, not to celebrate it; the bird's value lies in its resistance to symbolization, not in its symbolic wealth.
D
Incorrect because the poem is not concerned with birdwatching practices; its subject is the poetic impulse to symbolize, not the observational practices of ornithologists or hobbyists.

Studied alongside

Other concepts from Prose Fiction.