Read the following poem:
From the Dock Workers' Elegy
Their hands are in the concrete now.
Not metaphor — there is a story:
A worker who dropped his hand-mold
Before the pour set, and the company
Kept the slab and poured another morning
And his fingers are in the bridge's footing
Forever, which is perhaps more tribute
Than the plaque that was never erected.
The others went home to bad knees
And the specific silence of men
Who have done something that will stand
While they will not. This is what they built:
Not the bridge, exactly, but its permanence —
And permanence is what their bodies paid for.
The phrase 'the specific silence' in lines 9-10 most nearly characterizes:
- AA resentful silence aimed at employers who denied the workers the public recognition their labor plainly deserved.
- BA companionable quiet the men share on the long walk home after finishing a physically demanding project.
- CA literal inability to speak brought on by the occupational hearing loss common among industrial laborers.
- DA silence filled by knowing one has built something permanent while one's own body will not last.Correct
Why D is right
The word 'specific' does crucial work: it is not general silence but a silence with a precise content. The following lines identify it — 'men who have done something that will stand / While they will not.' The silence is shaped by the knowledge of one's own physical mortality against the permanence of what one's labor has made. It is not hostile (A), not the literal quiet of the workplace or walk home (B), and not physical (C) but existential.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- No hostility or resentment is attributed to the workers; the poem frames their silence as inward-looking, not directed at employers, and the missing plaque is noted without bitterness.
- B
- This misreads the silence as ordinary companionable quiet; 'specific' signals an interior, existential content, not the ambient calm of a shared walk home.
- C
- Occupational hearing loss is never mentioned; the silence is psycho-emotional, not physiological, and 'bad knees' is the only bodily toll the poem names.