Skip to content
AP Environmental Science · Living World: Ecosystems and Biodiversity

Bottom up control

Bottom up control appears in 5 reviewed AP Environmental Science questions and sits in Living World: Ecosystems and Biodiversity. Below are worked examples showing exactly how the exam tests it, with the answer marked and every distractor explained.

How Bottom up control is tested

Example 1Medium
In an experiment, researchers added fertilizer to several plots in a grassland. They found that plant biomass increased, which was followed by increases in insect herbivore populations, and eventually by increases in insectivorous bird populations. This experiment best supports which model of population regulation?
  1. ADensity-independent regulation, because fertilizer is not related to population density
  2. BIsland biogeography, because the experiment was conducted in small, isolated grassland plots that limited colonization by new species
  3. CTop-down control, because birds regulated insect populations
  4. DBottom-up control, because nutrient addition at the base of the food web increased populations at all higher trophic levelsCorrect

Why D is right

The experiment demonstrates bottom-up control because adding resources at the base of the food web (nutrients for plants) cascaded upward through the food chain. Increased plant biomass supported more herbivorous insects, which in turn supported more insectivorous birds. The regulation flowed from the bottom (producers) to the top (predators).
Why the other 3 choices miss
A
Incorrect because the population responses were mediated through density-dependent food web interactions (more food → more consumers). While the initial fertilizer addition was density-independent, the population responses throughout the food web were density-dependent resource-consumer interactions.
B
Incorrect because island biogeography theory explains species richness on islands (or habitat patches) based on immigration and extinction rates. The experiment measured trophic responses to nutrient addition in a grassland, not species richness or colonization of isolated plots.
C
Incorrect because while birds may regulate insects in some contexts, the experiment specifically shows regulation flowing from nutrients → plants → insects → birds. The driving force was resource addition at the base, not predator control from the top.
Example 2Harder
An ecologist hypothesizes that both top-down and bottom-up forces simultaneously regulate a stream ecosystem. Which experimental finding would best support this hypothesis?
  1. ARemoving predators increases herbivore populations, and adding nutrients increases primary producer biomass, with both effects propagating through the food webCorrect
  2. BOnly predator removal affects population sizes; nutrient addition has no measurable effect
  3. CNeither predator removal nor nutrient addition has any effect on any trophic level
  4. DOnly nutrient addition increases primary producer and herbivore populations; removing predators has no measurable effect on herbivore or producer abundance at any level

Why A is right

If both top-down and bottom-up forces operate simultaneously, then manipulating either end of the food web should produce measurable effects. Removing predators (testing top-down control) should increase herbivore populations, and adding nutrients (testing bottom-up control) should increase primary producer biomass. If both manipulations produce effects that cascade through the food web, it supports the hypothesis of dual regulation.
Why the other 3 choices miss
B
Incorrect because if only predator removal has an effect, this would support exclusively top-down control, not simultaneous top-down and bottom-up regulation.
C
Incorrect because if neither manipulation has any effect, it would suggest that neither top-down nor bottom-up forces regulate this ecosystem, contradicting the hypothesis entirely.
D
Incorrect because if only nutrient addition has an effect (even one that raises producer and herbivore populations), this would support exclusively bottom-up control, not simultaneous regulation by both forces.

Studied alongside

Other concepts from Living World: Ecosystems and Biodiversity.