An environmental scientist compares the lifecycle carbon emissions of different electricity generation methods. Which source would have the lowest lifecycle carbon emissions per kilowatt-hour?
- ANatural gas combined-cycle plant
- BCoal with carbon capture and storage
- CWind turbinesCorrect
- DOil-fired power plant
Why C is right
Wind turbines have among the lowest lifecycle carbon emissions of any electricity source. Their emissions come primarily from manufacturing and installation, with zero emissions during operation. Typical values are 7-15 g CO₂/kWh compared to 400-1,000+ for fossil fuels.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- Incorrect because natural gas combined-cycle plants still emit 350-500 g CO₂/kWh, far more than wind energy's lifecycle emissions.
- B
- Incorrect because even with carbon capture (which captures 85-90% of emissions), coal still has significant lifecycle emissions from mining, transport, and incomplete capture.
- D
- Incorrect because oil-fired plants have high carbon emissions (600-900 g CO₂/kWh), among the highest of fossil fuel sources.