Clear-cutting an entire forested watershed has multiple environmental consequences. Which immediate hydrological effect is most likely?
- AIncreased stream flow, erosion, and sedimentation due to loss of root systems and canopy interceptionCorrect
- BNo change in water quality because trees do not filter water
- CDecreased surface runoff because exposed soil absorbs more water
- DDecreased flooding risk because water flows more freely without tree obstructions
Why A is right
Clear-cutting removes the forest canopy (which intercepts and evaporates 15-30% of rainfall), eliminates transpiration (which returns water to the atmosphere), and destroys root systems (which stabilize soil and promote infiltration). The result is dramatically increased surface runoff, higher peak stream flows, accelerated bank and hillslope erosion, and increased sedimentation of streams.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- B
- Incorrect. Forests are highly effective at filtering water. Root systems stabilize soil, leaf litter absorbs rainfall impact, and forest soils filter nutrients and contaminants. Removing trees dramatically degrades water quality.
- C
- Incorrect. Exposed soil without root networks and organic matter actually has reduced infiltration capacity. Without canopy interception and root channels, more water runs off the surface rather than soaking in.
- D
- Incorrect. Deforestation increases flooding risk because rapid runoff without canopy interception creates higher peak flows. The Hubbard Brook experiment demonstrated this conclusively.