Which of the following describes 'net ecosystem production' (NEP) and what a positive NEP indicates about an ecosystem?
- ANEP = total respiration - photosynthesis; a positive NEP indicates the ecosystem releases more CO2 than it absorbs.
- BNEP = GPP - total ecosystem respiration; a positive NEP indicates the ecosystem is a net carbon sink, accumulating carbon.Correct
- CNEP = NPP - consumer respiration; a positive NEP indicates more energy enters the ecosystem than leaves.
- DNEP = NPP + decomposer respiration; a positive NEP indicates high decomposition rates in healthy soils.
Why B is right
Net Ecosystem Production (NEP) = GPP - total ecosystem respiration (all autotroph + heterotroph respiration). When GPP > total ER, NEP is positive, meaning the ecosystem is fixing more carbon through photosynthesis than it is releasing through all forms of respiration — it is accumulating organic carbon and serving as a net carbon sink. Young, rapidly growing forests and intact peatlands typically have positive NEP. Disturbed or decomposing ecosystems may have negative NEP (carbon sources).
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- This equation has the sign reversed; NEP = photosynthesis (GPP) - respiration (ER), not the reverse; a positive value from GPP - ER means more photosynthesis than respiration, indicating a carbon sink, not a carbon source.
- C
- NEP includes all respiration (heterotrophs + autotrophs), not just consumer respiration; and NEP is about carbon balance relative to photosynthesis, not about energy entering vs. leaving in the thermodynamic sense.
- D
- Adding decomposer respiration to NPP would not give NEP; decomposer respiration is a component of total ecosystem respiration that is subtracted from GPP to calculate NEP; high decomposition would contribute to negative, not positive, NEP.