Skip to content
AP Environmental Science · Living World: Ecosystems and Biodiversity

Limiting nutrients

Limiting nutrients appears in 3 reviewed AP Environmental Science questions and sits in Living World: Ecosystems and Biodiversity. Below are worked examples showing exactly how the exam tests it, with the answer marked and every distractor explained.

How Limiting nutrients is tested

Example 1Harder
Which of the following best describes the role of phosphorus in aquatic ecosystem productivity, and why it is often the limiting nutrient in freshwater systems?
  1. APhosphorus acidifies freshwater when present in excess, and most freshwater algae require slightly acidic conditions to photosynthesize efficiently
  2. BPhosphorus is the limiting nutrient in both marine and freshwater systems equally, because it is rapidly consumed by nitrogen-fixing bacteria before plants can use it
  3. CPhosphorus controls water temperature through its heat capacity, and cooler water holds more dissolved oxygen needed for plant growth
  4. DPhosphorus is needed for ATP, DNA, and cell membranes, and it limits freshwater growth because it binds tightly to sedimentsCorrect

Why D is right

Phosphorus is essential for ATP (energy currency), DNA (genetic material), and phospholipid cell membranes. In freshwater, phosphorus is limiting because it adsorbs strongly to sediment particles, making it unavailable to algae and plants. In marine systems, nitrogen is more often the limiting nutrient. This is why adding phosphate-rich fertilizers or detergents to freshwater triggers eutrophication.
Why the other 3 choices miss
A
Phosphorus does not acidify water; excess phosphorus causes eutrophication (algal blooms), not acidification. Acid rain from sulfur and nitrogen oxides acidifies freshwater.
B
Phosphorus is not the limiting nutrient in marine systems; nitrogen is typically limiting in marine environments, while phosphorus limits freshwater productivity.
C
Phosphorus does not control water temperature; the heat capacity of water is a physical property that does not involve dissolved nutrients.

Studied alongside

Other concepts from Living World: Ecosystems and Biodiversity.