Skip to content
AP Environmental Science · Land and Water Use

Natural capital

Natural capital appears in 4 reviewed AP Environmental Science questions and sits in Land and Water Use. Below are worked examples showing exactly how the exam tests it, with the answer marked and every distractor explained.

How Natural capital is tested

Example 1Harder
A coastal wetland management plan considers whether to allow drainage of a 500-hectare salt marsh for agricultural use. An ecosystem services assessment assigns the following annual values to the salt marsh: storm surge protection: $1,200/ha/year, fish nursery habitat: $800/ha/year, water filtration: $400/ha/year, carbon sequestration: $200/ha/year. Agricultural use would generate $500/ha/year. Which of the following calculations correctly evaluates whether conversion is economically justified?
  1. AConversion is not justified: total ecosystem services value ($2,600/ha/year) exceeds agricultural use value ($500/ha/year) by $2,100/ha/year.Correct
  2. BConversion is marginally justified: salt marsh value ($1,200/ha/year for storm protection) equals agricultural value ($500/ha/year) plus carbon value ($200/ha/year) = $700/ha/year.
  3. CConversion is justified: the $500/ha/year agricultural value is multiplied by 500 ha to get $250,000/year, while each ecosystem service is too small per hectare to matter.
  4. DConversion is justified: agricultural value ($500/ha/year) exceeds carbon sequestration value ($200/ha/year), the only relevant ecosystem service for regulatory purposes.

Why A is right

Total ecosystem services value = storm surge protection ($1,200) + fish nursery ($800) + water filtration ($400) + carbon sequestration ($200) = $2,600/ha/year. Agricultural value = $500/ha/year. The marsh provides $2,100/ha more annual value than agriculture. Over 500 ha, the difference = $2,100 × 500 = $1,050,000/year more value in its natural state. This type of ecosystem services valuation is the basis for natural capital accounting frameworks. While the values shown are simplified, real analyses (e.g., Costanza et al., 1997, 2014) show salt marshes, mangroves, and other wetlands typically have very high ecosystem service values that far exceed agricultural conversion values. The failure to account for these values in market transactions leads to under-protection of ecosystems.
Why the other 3 choices miss
B
Incorrect. This calculation selects only storm protection as the marsh value and compares it to the sum of agriculture + carbon, which is not the correct comparison. The full ecosystem services total ($2,600/ha/year) must be compared to the agricultural alternative ($500/ha/year).
C
Incorrect. Agricultural value must also be multiplied by 500 ha for a fair comparison, giving $250,000/year. But ecosystem services value = $2,600/ha × 500 ha = $1,300,000/year—still much more than agricultural value ($250,000/year). Scale does not favor conversion; it makes the absolute difference even larger.
D
Incorrect. An ecosystem services analysis must consider ALL services, not just carbon sequestration. Storm surge protection alone ($1,200/ha/year) exceeds agricultural value ($500/ha/year), before even adding other services. Restricting analysis to carbon alone artificially undervalues the marsh.

Studied alongside

Other concepts from Land and Water Use.