A conservation ecologist argues that a single large nature reserve is more effective for biodiversity conservation than several small reserves of equivalent total area. This argument is most consistent with which ecological principle?
- AIsland biogeography theory, which predicts that larger habitats support more speciesCorrect
- BThe principle of limiting factors, which predicts that the scarcest resource controls population size
- CThe competitive exclusion principle, which predicts that species with overlapping niches cannot coexist
- DThe intermediate disturbance hypothesis, which predicts maximum diversity at moderate disturbance levels
Why A is right
This is the SLOSS (Single Large Or Several Small) debate in conservation biology. The argument for a single large reserve is based on island biogeography theory: larger areas support larger populations (reducing extinction risk), contain more habitat types, and have proportionally less edge and more interior habitat. However, several small reserves may capture more habitat diversity in some landscapes.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- B
- Incorrect because the principle of limiting factors describes how individual resource availability controls population size, not the area-species relationship that underlies reserve design arguments.
- C
- Incorrect because the competitive exclusion principle addresses species coexistence in shared niches, not the relationship between habitat area and species richness relevant to reserve design.
- D
- Incorrect because the intermediate disturbance hypothesis relates to how disturbance frequency affects diversity, not to the relationship between reserve size and species richness.