A soil scientist analyzes two soil samples. Sample A has 40% sand, 40% silt, and 20% clay. Sample B has 70% sand, 20% silt, and 10% clay. Which comparison of their properties is most accurate?
- ASample A drains faster because its higher silt content creates larger pore spaces
- BSample A has higher water-holding capacity and lower permeability than Sample BCorrect
- CBoth samples have identical drainage properties because they contain the same mineral types
- DSample B has higher water-holding capacity and better nutrient retention than Sample A
Why B is right
Sample A has more clay and silt (60% combined vs. 30% in Sample B), giving it smaller particle sizes and pore spaces. Smaller pores retain water through capillary action, increasing water-holding capacity. The smaller pores also slow water movement, reducing permeability (drainage rate). Sample B's higher sand content creates larger pores that drain quickly.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- Incorrect. Silt particles are smaller than sand particles and create smaller pore spaces, not larger ones. Higher silt content slows drainage rather than speeding it up.
- C
- Incorrect. Drainage properties depend on particle size distribution, not just mineral type. The significant difference in sand, silt, and clay proportions between the samples produces very different drainage characteristics.
- D
- Incorrect. Sample B's higher sand content (70%) creates large pore spaces that drain quickly, resulting in lower water-holding capacity and poorer nutrient retention compared to Sample A's finer texture.