On this page · 5 sections
Section II of AP Environmental Science gives you three free-response questions in 70 minutes, and the section counts for 40 percent of your exam score. Each question is worth 10 points, so the whole section is 30 raw points, and every one of them is earned by a specific sentence you write.
The three questions have fixed jobs. Question 1 asks you to design an investigation, so you state a hypothesis, name the independent and dependent variables, pick a control, and say what you would hold constant. It also mixes in content parts about the environmental topic behind the experiment. Question 2 asks you to analyze an environmental problem and propose a solution, usually built around a short description, a graph, a map or a data table. Question 3 has the same shape as Question 2, but one or more of its parts are calculations, often with several steps.
Readers score each question against a point-by-point rubric in which each point names one thing a response must do, such as identify a correct variable or explain a correct cause. The reader looks for that thing, awards the point or does not, and moves on, because nothing is given for length, style, an introduction or a summary. Each part is scored on its own, so a weak answer in part (b) does not stop you earning points in part (c). If part (c) uses your number from part (b), show your setup clearly, because many rubrics give the setup point, and sometimes the answer point, for correct work done with your earlier value.
The task verb tells you how much to write. Identify wants a short, specific answer, often one phrase. Describe wants the features of something, with no cause required. Explain wants a cause and its effect, linked by a mechanism. Justify wants your claim tied to evidence, usually the data in front of you. Calculate wants the setup, the arithmetic and a final answer with units. Propose a solution wants a specific action someone could actually take.
On the calculation parts, the work is part of the answer, and a bare number with no setup often earns nothing even when it is right. Units matter too, because an answer of 36,000 is incomplete when the question was about metric tons of carbon dioxide per year. A calculator is allowed, but it cannot write the setup for you.
The steps
- 1
1. Split the 70 minutes before you start
Seventy minutes across three questions is about 23 minutes each. Plan on roughly 20 minutes for Question 1, 22 for Question 2 and 25 for Question 3, because the calculation question has the most steps. That split is our recommendation, not a College Board rule, so adjust it to your strengths. Watch the clock at the 20 and 42 minute marks, which are the ends of Question 1 and Question 2, so that you keep about 25 minutes for Question 3 and a few minutes to review. If one part has you stuck for more than two minutes, write your best partial answer and move on, because a blank part scores zero while a half-right setup on a calculation can still earn a point.
- 2
2. Count the asks in every part
Before you write, read each part and mark three things on your scratch paper: the verb, the number, and the object. A part that asks you to identify two sources of methane wants exactly two, not one and not five. If a part asks for one answer and you give several, readers usually score only the first one, or the first two when two are asked for, and they ignore any extras even if those are right. So put your best answer first, and do not contradict yourself within an answer. Also check whether a part asks about the stimulus specifically, because if it names the graph or the passage, your answer has to use it.
- 3
3. Pull the facts out of the stimulus
Read the stimulus with the questions already in mind. On a graph, read the axis labels and units first, then note the trend and any point where it changes, and on a data table, find the row or column each part will need. Write down every number you will use, with its units, before you calculate anything, because many lost points come from reading kilograms as grams or years as months. If the passage describes a place, note what is unusual about it, such as a coastal aquifer, a steep slope or a town downwind of a smelter.
- 4
4. Match the length of each answer to its verb
For an identify part, one precise phrase is enough, such as nitrogen oxides or deforestation, while a describe part needs a feature or a trend in one or two sentences. For an explain part, write a short chain: what happens, what that causes, and why. Sulfur dioxide from coal combustion forms sulfuric acid in the atmosphere, which falls as acid deposition and lowers the pH of lakes, so fish eggs fail to develop. That is an explanation, but saying acid rain hurts fish is only a claim. Use the correct term, such as eutrophication, biomagnification or albedo, but follow it with the mechanism, because the term by itself rarely earns an explain point.
- 5
5. Write every calculation as a chain of units
Start each calculation by writing the quantity you were given, with its units. Multiply by conversion factors so the unwanted units cancel, and keep going until only the units you want are left; for example, 36,000 MWh times 1,000 kWh per MWh gives 36,000,000 kWh. No formula sheet is printed for this exam, so you need the core relationships memorized, including percent change, the rule of 70 for doubling time, and half-life. Use scientific notation for very large or small numbers, and round only at the end. Then write the final answer with units and mark it clearly.
- 6
6. Build the experiment parts from the variables out
On Question 1, name the independent variable first, because everything else follows from it. It is the one thing the researcher changes on purpose, such as the amount of fertilizer added, while the dependent variable is what gets measured, such as algae growth in grams. The control group gets no treatment, so it shows what happens without the change, and constants are the conditions kept the same across all groups, such as water temperature and light. A testable hypothesis is a prediction about how the independent variable affects the dependent variable that the experiment could support or refute. A directional prediction such as more fertilizer will increase algae growth is a safe choice, and a clearly stated null hypothesis, such as fertilizer amount will have no effect on algae growth, is also usually accepted. Repeated trials make results more reliable, and you can say so when a part asks how to improve the design.
- 7
7. Make each solution specific, then use leftover time
A proposed solution must be an action someone could take, not a wish, so planting riparian buffer strips along the creek is a solution but reducing pollution is not. When a part asks for a benefit or a drawback, tie it to the solution you just gave, not to some other policy. Then use any time left to reread. Check that every part has an answer, that each calculation shows its setup and units, and that your answers in neighboring parts do not contradict each other.
Worked through
Here is an original practice question written in the style of Question 3, with a model response and a note on where each point comes from. The 10-point breakdown below is our own illustration, not a released rubric.
The stimulus. The town of Ridgeway uses 120,000 megawatt-hours (MWh) of electricity per year, and all of it comes from a coal-fired power plant that releases about 1.0 metric ton of carbon dioxide for every MWh it generates. The town council proposes a solar farm that would supply 30 percent of the town's yearly electricity. The solar farm would cost $54 million to build, and every kilowatt-hour (kWh) it produces would save the town $0.06 in coal electricity costs.
(a) Identify one air pollutant other than carbon dioxide that coal combustion releases, and describe one effect it has on human health or the environment. (2 points)
(b) Calculate how many metric tons of carbon dioxide the town would avoid each year once the solar farm is running. Show your work. (2 points)
(c) Calculate how many years it would take for the solar farm's savings to pay back its construction cost. Show your work. (2 points)
(d) Identify one environmental drawback of building a large solar farm, and explain how that drawback could harm a local ecosystem. (2 points)
(e) The solar farm produces no electricity at night. Propose one solution that would let the town keep using solar electricity after sunset, and explain one way that cutting carbon dioxide emissions would benefit ocean ecosystems. (2 points)
Model response.
(a) Coal combustion releases sulfur dioxide, which reacts with water in the atmosphere to form sulfuric acid that falls as acid deposition. This lowers the pH of lakes and streams, and the acidic water can kill fish eggs and leach toxic aluminum from soil.
Why it scores 2 of 2. The first point is for naming a correct pollutant, and nitrogen oxides, particulate matter or mercury would also work. The second point is for a correct effect linked to that same pollutant. If the student had named sulfur dioxide and then described ozone depletion, the second point would be lost, because sulfur dioxide is not the cause of stratospheric ozone loss.
(b) Solar supplies 30 percent of 120,000 MWh. 120,000 MWh x 0.30 = 36,000 MWh per year. 36,000 MWh x 1.0 metric ton CO2 per MWh = 36,000 metric tons of CO2 avoided per year.
Why it scores 2 of 2. One point is for a correct setup that shows both steps, and the other is for the correct answer with units. A student who wrote only 36,000 would likely lose at least one point, because there is no setup and no unit.
(c) First convert MWh to kWh: 36,000 MWh x 1,000 kWh per MWh = 36,000,000 kWh per year. Savings: 36,000,000 kWh x $0.06 per kWh = $2,160,000 per year. Payback: $54,000,000 divided by $2,160,000 per year = 25 years.
Why it scores 2 of 2. The setup includes the unit conversion, which is where this part is most often lost. A student who skipped the conversion would get $2,160 per year and a payback of 25,000 years. That student could still earn the setup point for dividing cost by yearly savings, but not the answer point.
(d) One drawback is habitat loss, because a large solar farm clears many acres of land. If the land was grassland, the ground-nesting birds and burrowing animals that lived there lose their food and shelter, so their populations shrink, and so do the predators that depend on them.
Why it scores 2 of 2. The identify point is for habitat loss, and the explain point is for a real chain from clearing land to a harm in the ecosystem. Writing only that solar farms are bad for animals would earn the first point at most.
(e) The town could install large batteries that store extra solar electricity during the day and release it at night. Cutting carbon dioxide emissions would also help oceans, because less carbon dioxide in the air means less dissolves into seawater to form carbonic acid. The ocean's pH would fall more slowly, so corals, clams and other organisms that build calcium carbonate shells would have more carbonate ions available to build them.
Why it scores 2 of 2. The solution is specific and actually solves the night problem, while saying the town should use less electricity at night would not, because it does not keep solar power running. The ocean point needs the acidification mechanism, and a common error is to blame coral bleaching on acidification. Bleaching is caused by warmer water, which makes corals expel the algae that live in their tissue, while acidification is a separate harm to shell-building.
What a 5-point response looks like. Most mid-range answers on this question lose points in predictable places. They name sulfur dioxide but link it to the ozone hole, write 36,000 with no setup or units, and skip the MWh to kWh conversion. They say solar is bad for wildlife without naming a mechanism, and they link lower emissions to bleaching instead of shell-building. Every one of those is fixable with the steps above.
Common mistakes
Giving a bare number on a calculation part with no setup and no units. The setup is often a point on its own, and an answer without units is incomplete.
Skipping a unit conversion, such as MWh to kWh or grams to kilograms. The setup can still earn a point, but the final answer will be off by a factor of 1,000.
Writing a claim when the part says explain. Saying fertilizer runoff is bad for fish is not an explanation. Runoff adds nitrogen, algae bloom and die, and decomposers use up the dissolved oxygen, so fish suffocate.
Mixing up the independent and dependent variables, or treating the control group and the constants as the same thing. The control gets no treatment, while constants are conditions held the same for every group.
Pairing a pollutant with the wrong effect, such as blaming carbon dioxide for the ozone hole or blaming coral bleaching on ocean acidification.
Proposing a vague goal instead of an action, such as reduce pollution or protect the habitat, or giving a drawback that belongs to a different solution.
Checklist
- I can name what each of the three questions always asks for: an investigation, a problem with a solution, and a problem with calculations.
- I can tell the difference between identify, describe, explain and justify, and write an answer of the right length for each.
- I can name the independent variable, dependent variable, control group and two constants for an experiment I have never seen before.
- I can write a calculation as a chain of units that cancel, including MWh to kWh and percent change.
- I can calculate doubling time with the rule of 70 and remaining mass after several half-lives without a formula sheet.
- I can explain a pollutant's effect as a chain of cause and result, not just name the harm.
- I can propose a solution that is a specific action and give a benefit or drawback that belongs to that same solution.
- I can finish all three questions in 70 minutes with every part answered.