The following is a practice passage in which a speaker in a regional council debate in a hypothetical aging country argues for a policy.
When our pension system was built, five workers paid into it for every retiree. Today the ratio is barely two to one, and our clinics are filling with patients over eighty. I support admitting more newcomers, and I want to be honest about my reasons. I do not expect them to raise our birth rate; within a generation their families are as small as ours. I do not claim they will open many shops, and I accept that many will send part of their wages home. What matters is that they arrive in their twenties and thirties, and every paycheck they earn carries a contribution to the funds our elders depend on.
Which of the following findings, if true, would most seriously weaken the speaker's argument?
- AMost newcomers admitted under the policy work off the books in cash-paid jobs, so no payroll or social insurance contributions are deducted from their earningsCorrect
- BNewcomers send roughly a fifth of their earnings to relatives in their home countries each month
- CFew newcomers establish their own businesses during their first ten years in the country
- DThe fertility rate of newcomers' daughters closely matches that of native-born women of the same age
- ENewcomers are paid wages roughly equal to those of native-born workers doing the same jobs
Why A is right
The speaker's argument rests on one mechanism: young working-age newcomers raise the worker-to-retiree ratio because 'every paycheck they earn carries a contribution to the funds our elders depend on.' This is the dependency-ratio argument for immigration in aging countries. Choice A attacks that mechanism directly: if newcomers' earnings are never taxed for social insurance, their arrival does nothing to fund pensions or elder healthcare. The passage itself concedes or sets aside the other claims (low long-term fertility, few new businesses, remittances), and it does not depend on wage levels, so none of those findings weakens the argument.
Why the other 4 choices miss
- B
- The speaker already accepts that many newcomers will send part of their wages home, so evidence of remittances does not contradict the argument. The case depends on contributions from paychecks earned in the country, not on how the rest of those wages is spent.
- C
- The speaker explicitly declines to claim that newcomers will open many shops, so finding little entrepreneurship leaves the argument intact.
- D
- The speaker already concedes that newcomer families become as small as native families within a generation. Fertility convergence matches the passage and does not weaken it.
- E
- The passage makes no argument about wage levels. Wages equal to native workers' would, if anything, mean larger contributions to the pension and health funds and so would support the speaker.