The table shows hypothetical data for five rice-importing countries between Year 1 and Year 5.
| Country | Rice import tariff, Year 1 to Year 5 (%) | Farm-gate rice price, Year 5 ($/ton) | Smallholder production cost, Year 5 ($/ton) | Change in rice-farming households, Year 1-5 (%) | Change in urban share of population, Year 1-5 (percentage points) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| V | 45 to 45 | 410 | 350 | -2 | +1 |
| W | 50 to 0 | 300 | 370 | -24 | +7 |
| X | 40 to 0 | 380 | 330 | -3 | +2 |
| Y | 35 to 35 | 290 | 360 | -20 | +6 |
| Z | 30 to 0 | 310 | 340 | -4 | +1 |
Which country's data best support the claim that eliminating rice import tariffs can push domestic prices below smallholder production costs and drive rural-to-urban migration?
- ACountry Z, where the tariff fell to zero, the farm-gate price fell below cost, and the urban share rose 7 points
- BCountry Y, where the tariff fell to zero, the farm-gate price fell below cost, and rice households fell by a fifth
- CCountry X, where the tariff fell to zero, the farm-gate price fell below cost, and rice households fell by 24 percent
- DCountry W, where the tariff fell to zero, the farm-gate price fell $70 below cost, rice households fell 24 percent, and the urban share rose 7 pointsCorrect
- ECountry V, where the farm-gate price fell $60 below cost and rice households declined while the urban share rose
Why D is right
Only Country W shows all three parts of the claim in the table. Its tariff went from 50 percent to 0. Its Year 5 farm-gate price ($300) is $70 below smallholder production cost ($370). Rice-farming households fell 24 percent while the urban share rose 7 points, which is consistent with farmers leaving agriculture for cities. This matches the pattern geographers describe when cheap, often subsidized, imported rice enters a liberalized market and undercuts smallholders. Z and X also removed tariffs but show little household loss or urbanization, and X's price stays above cost. Y shows displacement without any tariff change, and V shows neither liberalization nor displacement.
Why the other 4 choices miss
- A
- Wrong-row misreading: Z did drop its tariff and its price ($310) is below cost ($340), but its urban share rose only 1 point and rice households fell just 4 percent. The +7 belongs to Country W, so Z shows no clear migration.
- B
- Unsupported causal leap: Y's price ($290) is below cost ($360) and households fell 20 percent, but Y's tariff stayed at 35 percent. Y's decline cannot be credited to tariff elimination.
- C
- Misreads X: X removed its tariff, but its farm-gate price ($380) stays above production cost ($330), and households fell only 3 percent. The 24 percent figure belongs to Country W.
- E
- Reverses V's numbers: V's price ($410) is $60 above cost, not below. V kept its 45 percent tariff, and its households and urban share barely changed.